Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, New York, NY.
Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, British Hospital of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Aesthet Surg J. 2020 Jun 15;40(7):703-709. doi: 10.1093/asj/sjz303.
The goal of facial feminization surgery (FFS) is to feminize the sexually dimorphic characteristics of the face and enable transwomen to be correctly gendered as female. Studies have demonstrated high patient satisfaction with FFS. However, the correct gendering of patients after FFS has never been objectively studied.
The aim of this study was to determine if FFS changed the perceived gender of patients in the public eye.
An online survey platform with control photographs of cis-gender males and cis-gender females as well as preoperative and postoperative FFS patients was created. Respondents were asked to identify patients as "male" or "female" and to assign a confidence score ranging from -10 (masculine) to +10 (feminine) (n = 802).
Cis-gender male and female controls were gendered correctly 99% and 99.38% of the time and with a confidence metric (CM) of -8.96 and 8.93, respectively. Preoperative FFS patients were gendered as female 57.31% of the time with a CM of 1.41 despite hormone therapy, makeup, and hairstyle. Postoperative FFS patients were gendered as female 94.27% of the time with a CM of 7.78. Ninety-five percent of patients showed a significant improvement in CM after FFS.
This study illustrates that FFS changes the social perception of a patient's gender. Patients after FFS are more likely to be identified as female and with greater confidence than before surgery. This is despite preoperative female hormone therapy, and nonsurgical methods that patients use to feminize their appearance.
面部女性化手术(FFS)的目标是使具有性别二态性的面部特征女性化,并使跨性别女性能够被正确地性别认同为女性。研究表明,FFS 患者的满意度很高。然而,FFS 后患者的正确性别认同从未被客观研究过。
本研究旨在确定 FFS 是否改变了公众对患者的性别认知。
创建了一个带有顺性别男性和顺性别女性的对照照片以及术前和术后 FFS 患者的在线调查平台。受访者被要求将患者识别为“男性”或“女性”,并分配一个从-10(男性化)到+10(女性化)的置信得分(n=802)。
顺性别男性和女性对照的正确性别识别率分别为 99%和 99.38%,置信度量(CM)分别为-8.96 和 8.93。尽管接受了激素治疗、化妆和发型,术前 FFS 患者仍有 57.31%的时间被识别为女性,CM 为 1.41。术后 FFS 患者有 94.27%的时间被识别为女性,CM 为 7.78。95%的患者在 FFS 后 CM 显著改善。
本研究表明,FFS 改变了社会对患者性别的认知。FFS 后的患者更有可能被识别为女性,并且比手术前更有信心。这是尽管术前使用了女性激素治疗和患者用来使自己外表女性化的非手术方法。