Sharrad Dale F, Schultz David W
Department of Medicine, Flinders Medical Centre, Bedford Park, Australia.
Centre for Neuroscience, Flinders University, Bedford Park, Australia.
Amyotroph Lateral Scler Frontotemporal Degener. 2019 Nov;20(sup1):289-300. doi: 10.1080/21678421.2019.1646998.
MND is a progressive neurodegenerative disease characterised by death of upper and lower motor neurons, leading to progressive weakness of the bulbar, limb, thoracic and abdominal muscles. MND has a fairly stereotypical course, with death from respiratory failure occurring 2-4 years after symptom onset in most cases (1). Making the diagnosis of MND can be straightforward when key clinical criteria are met; however, at first presentation, rarely do patients meet these criteria, neurological changes may be subtle and disease progression slow. Thus, diagnosis poses a significant challenge, particularly in general practice, where patients are most likely to first present. Not surprisingly, there is usually a delay of 10-18 months between symptom onset and MND diagnosis (2). Importantly, early assessment by a neurologist is associated with a shorter time to MND diagnosis (3), which has significant implications for access to healthcare, including Riluzole and multidisciplinary clinics, which improve survival (4). Although delay in diagnosis is well documented, there have been no studies that have sought to identify factors associated with time to diagnosis, thereby enabling targeted implementation of a public health intervention. To characterise the clinical factors that influence time to diagnosis of MND. 112 patients with MND attending the Southern Adelaide MND Clinic enrolled between January 2016 - 2018 were retrospectively recruited in to a cohort study. Information pertaining to the patient's demographics and their journey to diagnosis collected by a specialist physician and stored in the Australian MND Registry during clinic review were analysed to identify factors associated with time to diagnosis. Mean time to diagnosis was 13 ± 1 months (range 1 - 38 months) from symptom onset. 41% of patients were classified as having fast disease progression; compared to those with slow disease progression, these patients were diagnosed earlier (8 ± 1 months vs 16 ± 2 months) ( < 0.0001, = 34.6, df =220), were less likely to undergo multiple specialist opinions prior to referral to a neurologist (53% vs 73%) ( < 0.05, = 9.5, df =1), and were more disabled at time of diagnosis (mean ALSFRS-R 33 ± 5 vs ALSFRS-R 41 ± 5) ( < 0.0001, = 12.4, df =220). Fast disease progression identifies a dichotomy of MND patients diagnosed earlier, although more disabled at diagnosis, likely mediated by a more efficient referral process. A greater awareness of MND is required to shorten time to diagnosis.
运动神经元病(MND)是一种进行性神经退行性疾病,其特征是上下运动神经元死亡,导致延髓、肢体、胸部和腹部肌肉进行性无力。MND病程相当典型,大多数情况下,症状出现后2 - 4年因呼吸衰竭死亡(1)。当满足关键临床标准时,MND的诊断可能很直接;然而,在初次就诊时,患者很少能满足这些标准,神经学变化可能很细微,疾病进展缓慢。因此,诊断构成了重大挑战,尤其是在全科医疗中,患者最有可能首先在此就诊。不出所料,症状出现到MND诊断之间通常有10 - 18个月的延迟(2)。重要的是,由神经科医生进行早期评估与MND诊断时间缩短相关(3),这对获得医疗保健有重大影响,包括使用利鲁唑和多学科诊所,这些可提高生存率(4)。尽管诊断延迟有充分记录,但尚无研究试图确定与诊断时间相关的因素,从而无法有针对性地实施公共卫生干预措施。为了描述影响MND诊断时间的临床因素。对2016年1月至2018年期间在南阿德莱德MND诊所就诊的112例MND患者进行回顾性招募,纳入一项队列研究。在诊所复诊期间,由专科医生收集并存储在澳大利亚MND登记处的与患者人口统计学特征及其诊断过程相关的信息,被用于分析以确定与诊断时间相关的因素。从症状出现到诊断的平均时间为13±1个月(范围1 - 38个月)。41%的患者被归类为疾病进展迅速;与疾病进展缓慢的患者相比,这些患者诊断更早(8±1个月对16±2个月)(P<0.0001,χ² = 34.6,自由度 = 220),在转诊至神经科医生之前接受多次专科意见的可能性较小(53%对73%)(P<0.05,χ² = 9.5,自由度 = 1),并且在诊断时残疾程度更高(平均肌萎缩侧索硬化功能评分量表修订版[ALSFRS - R]为33±5对ALSFRS - R为41±5)(P<0.0001,χ² = 12.4,自由度 = 220)。疾病进展迅速表明MND患者存在一种二分法,即诊断较早,但诊断时残疾程度更高,这可能是由更有效的转诊过程介导的。需要提高对MND的认识以缩短诊断时间。