University of Brighton, School of Sport and Service Management, UK.
Nottingham Trent University, School of Science & Technology, UK.
J Sci Med Sport. 2020 Mar;23(3):237-240. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2019.10.014. Epub 2019 Oct 31.
To explore the provision of medical care at 'unlicensed', full-contact amateur and lower-level professional combat sports competitions in England.
Qualitative, mixed methods.
Observations totalling 200h of fieldwork shadowing medical professionals at 27 individual combat sports events, alongside formal, semi-structured interviews with 25 medical professionals, 7 referees and 9 promoters/event staff.
Practices and standards vary widely. Event organisers and promoters often have very little understanding of how different types of medical practitioners operate. They rarely, if ever, check that the staff they are hiring are qualified, sometimes resulting in unqualified staff being used to provide medical cover at events. Venues are often poorly equipped to accommodate basic medical procedures. Patient confidentiality is very often compromised. Medical professionals often have limited autonomy within the combat sports milieu and may find themselves marginalised, with their judgements overruled by non-medical staff during competitive events. Some practitioners are cognisant of the dangers such working environments pose to their professional reputations and livelihoods, but remain working within combat sports regardless.
Despite pockets of good practice, the lack of standardised rules for medical care provision creates substantial risks to athletes, to practitioners and the standing of the profession. The development and implementation of standardised, enforceable regulatory frameworks for full-contact combat sports in England is urgently needed.
探索在英国“无照”、全接触业余和低级别职业格斗运动比赛中提供医疗服务的情况。
定性,混合方法。
观察总计 200 小时的现场工作,跟踪 27 项个别格斗运动赛事中的医疗专业人员,同时对 25 名医疗专业人员、7 名裁判和 9 名推广人/赛事工作人员进行正式的、半结构化访谈。
做法和标准差异很大。赛事组织者和推广人通常对不同类型的医疗从业者的运作方式了解甚少。他们很少甚至从不检查他们雇用的员工是否合格,有时导致不合格的员工被用来在赛事中提供医疗服务。场馆通常设备简陋,无法进行基本的医疗程序。患者的保密性经常受到损害。医疗专业人员在格斗运动环境中往往自主权有限,他们的判断可能会在竞技赛事中被非医疗人员否决,从而被边缘化。一些从业者意识到这种工作环境对他们的职业声誉和生计构成的危险,但仍在格斗运动中工作。
尽管存在一些良好的实践,但医疗服务提供缺乏标准化规则,这给运动员、从业者和该行业的地位带来了巨大的风险。迫切需要在英格兰为全接触格斗运动制定和实施标准化、可执行的监管框架。