Forensic Medicine Unit, National Institute for Health and Welfare (THL), P.O. Box 310, FI-90101, Oulu, Finland.
Department of Forensic Medicine, Research Unit of Internal Medicine, Medical Research Center Oulu, University of Oulu, P.O. Box 5000, FI-90014, Oulu, Finland.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2020 Mar;16(1):65-70. doi: 10.1007/s12024-019-00193-4. Epub 2019 Nov 18.
The medico-legal autopsy is an essential tool in investigating deaths caused by an adverse event in health care, for both clinical risk management and for professional liability issues. However, there are no statistics available regarding the frequency of autopsies performed due to suspected adverse events. This study aimed to determine the number of medico-legal autopsies done because of presumed adverse events, whether these events were unintentional, medical errors or cases in which malpractice was suspected. Furthermore, differences in treatment types, causes and manner of death were analyzed. The data was obtained from all medico-legal autopsies performed in Northern Finland and Lapland during 2014-2015 (n = 2027). Adverse events were suspected in 181 (8.9%) cases. The suspicions of an adverse event occurring were most often related to medication, gastrointestinal surgery and orthopedic surgery. The manner of death was classified as medical (or surgical) treatment or investigative procedure in 22 (12.2%) cases. The causes of death were completely unrelated to the suspected adverse event in 41 (22.7%) cases. In conclusion, the frequency of presumed adverse events was quite high in this data set, but in the majority of the cases, the suspicion of an adverse event causing death was disproved by an autopsy. Nonetheless, proper investigation of these cases is essential to ensure legal protection of the deceased, next of kin and health care personnel, as well as to support clinical risk management.
法医学尸检是调查医疗保健中因不良事件导致的死亡的重要工具,既用于临床风险管理,也用于专业责任问题。然而,目前尚无关于因疑似不良事件而进行尸检的频率的统计数据。本研究旨在确定因疑似不良事件而进行的法医解剖数量,以及这些事件是否为非故意的、医疗差错或涉嫌医疗事故。此外,还分析了治疗类型、死因和死亡方式的差异。该数据来自 2014 年至 2015 年期间在芬兰北部和拉普兰进行的所有法医解剖(n=2027)。在 181 例(8.9%)病例中怀疑存在不良事件。发生不良事件的怀疑通常与药物、胃肠道手术和骨科手术有关。22 例(12.2%)病例的死亡方式被归类为医疗(或手术)治疗或调查程序。41 例(22.7%)病例的死亡原因与疑似不良事件完全无关。总之,在本数据集不良事件的推测频率相当高,但在大多数情况下,尸检证明了怀疑不良事件导致死亡的假设是错误的。然而,对这些病例进行适当的调查对于确保死者、近亲以及医护人员的法律保护,以及支持临床风险管理至关重要。