Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Resource and Environment, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China.
Department of Agroforestry and Environment, Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman Agricultural University Gazipur Bangladesh, Gazipur 1706, Bangladesh.
Sci Total Environ. 2019 Dec 1;694:133689. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.133689. Epub 2019 Aug 2.
Sustainable land use is a fundamental research field for land use planning. However, regional policymakers often lack access to the theoretical impacts that a land use policy might have on local development, especially in remote agricultural areas. Furthermore, knowledge exchange is important, especially in the context of globalization. This research employed the Framework of Participatory Impact Assessment and household surveys to combine multilevel stakeholders and comprehensively assessed the impacts of different land management scenarios on land use functions (LUFs) and local sustainable development. We completed this comparative study in typical remote agricultural areas in Godagari upazila of Bangladesh, Guyuan of China and Noto of Japan, which all have gradient differences in terms of their economic and social aspects, natural conditions and main land use issues. The selected scenarios were business as usual, increase in agricultural input and reform of rural development mode. The main conclusions are as follows: (1) the farmers at the three study sites all showed a decreasing dependence on their land and a relevant level of stress on environmental LUFs, but the rooted reasons were different and even opposing; (2) scenarios with a high aggregate impact on LUFs might not enable a sustainable development model, and the assessment of land management measures should consider the balance among environmental, economic and social dimensions; and (3) land use and management practices should be conducted with consideration of local conditions, and protecting agricultural development and enacting appropriate agricultural reforms could revitalize local agricultural development. The results revealed the demand for location-specific land management practices and underlined the knowledge of agricultural management on an international scale.
可持续土地利用是土地利用规划的一个基础研究领域。然而,区域政策制定者往往无法了解土地利用政策可能对当地发展产生的理论影响,特别是在偏远的农业地区。此外,知识交流很重要,尤其是在全球化的背景下。本研究采用参与式影响评估框架和入户调查相结合的方法,汇集了多层次的利益相关者,全面评估了不同土地管理情景对土地利用功能(LUFs)和当地可持续发展的影响。我们在孟加拉国戈达里县、中国固原市和日本能登市这三个典型的偏远农业地区完成了这项比较研究,这些地区在经济和社会方面、自然条件和主要土地利用问题上都存在梯度差异。选择的情景分别为:现状、增加农业投入和农村发展模式改革。主要结论如下:(1)三个研究点的农民对土地的依赖程度都呈下降趋势,对环境 LUFs 的压力也相应增大,但根本原因不同,甚至相反;(2)对 LUFs 有高度综合影响的情景可能无法实现可持续发展模式,土地管理措施的评估应考虑环境、经济和社会维度之间的平衡;(3)土地利用和管理实践应考虑到当地条件,保护农业发展和制定适当的农业改革可以振兴当地农业发展。研究结果揭示了对特定于位置的土地管理实践的需求,并强调了国际范围内的农业管理知识。