Zhu Y Y, Lee W, Botvinick E, Dae M, Chatterjee K, Danforth J, Ports T
Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco 94143.
Am Heart J. 1988 Oct;116(4):1071-80. doi: 10.1016/0002-8703(88)90162-7.
In order to determine their significance during dipyridamole perfusion scintigraphy, symptomatic, ECG, and scintigraphic findings were related to each other, to the hemodynamic response, and to angiographic findings in 73 consecutive patients having coronary angiography within 3 months of scintigraphy. The group having induced "cardiac" pain differed from the group without induced pain only in their higher incidence of induced ischemic ST changes, the "marked" hemodynamic response, and their lower incidence of an "absent" hemodynamic response (all p less than 0.01). Induced ST depression was found only in patients with coronary disease. In this population, dipyridamole-induced pain was a moderately specific marker and induced ST abnormalities a more highly specific marker for coronary disease. However, both were insensitive for coronary disease diagnosis. If induced pain or ST abnormalities in the presence of significant coronary disease were accepted as indicators of ischemia, then scintigraphic abnormalities appeared to be produced by dipyridamole in roughly equal incidence by ischemic and nonischemic mechanisms. Induced ischemia related frequently to an exaggerated hypotensive response with no change in double product, suggesting its cause to be an induced increase in myocardial oxygen demand. Dipyridamole-induced image defects were noted even in the absence of a peripheral hemodynamic response. This indicates that the peripheral response does not always correlate with its central coronary effect and an absent peripheral hemodynamic response does not necessarily invalidate scintigraphic results.
为了确定双嘧达莫灌注闪烁扫描期间这些表现的意义,对73例在闪烁扫描后3个月内接受冠状动脉造影的连续患者的症状、心电图及闪烁扫描结果进行了相互关联分析,并与血流动力学反应及血管造影结果进行了关联。诱发“心脏”疼痛的组与未诱发疼痛的组相比,仅在诱发缺血性ST段改变的发生率较高、“显著”血流动力学反应以及“无”血流动力学反应的发生率较低方面存在差异(所有p均小于0.01)。仅在冠心病患者中发现诱发的ST段压低。在这一人群中,双嘧达莫诱发的疼痛是冠心病的中度特异性标志物,而诱发的ST段异常是冠心病的更高度特异性标志物。然而,两者对冠心病诊断均不敏感。如果将存在显著冠心病时诱发的疼痛或ST段异常视为缺血的指标,那么闪烁扫描异常似乎由双嘧达莫通过缺血和非缺血机制产生的发生率大致相等。诱发的缺血常与双乘积无变化的过度降压反应相关,提示其原因是心肌需氧量的诱发增加。即使在没有外周血流动力学反应的情况下也可发现双嘧达莫诱发的图像缺损。这表明外周反应并不总是与其冠状动脉中心效应相关,且外周血流动力学反应缺失不一定会使闪烁扫描结果无效。