Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition, Geneva, Switzerland.
National Coordination of the Prospera Program of Social Inclusion, Mexico City, Mexico.
J Nutr. 2019 Dec 1;149(Suppl 1):2277S-2280S. doi: 10.1093/jn/nxz188.
The Progresa Conditional Cash Transfer program in Mexico began in 1997, with a strong evidence-based design. The program's ultimate objective was to foster the development of human capital through 3 components-education, health, and food. Rigorous impact evaluation generated evidence of impact on several outcomes, including child growth, but also aspects of program design and implementation challenges that may have limited impact. The objective of this supplement is to present research that led to the redesign of the health component, its implementation and evaluation at pilot scale, and its scale-up to national level, representing >15 y of collaboration among evaluators, program implementers, and funders. The studies used various methodologies, including process evaluation, cohort studies, ethnographic assessments, and a cluster-randomized trial, among others. The articles report previously unpublished results and citations of published literature. Article 1 uses an impact pathway to highlight gaps and bottlenecks that limited potential for greater impact, the original recognition of which was the impetus for this long collaboration. Article 2 explores the social and cultural factors that influence decisions to participate in programs and to adopt the actions proposed by them. Article 3 presents a cluster-randomized trial implemented to inform the choice of nutritional supplements for pregnant and lactating women and children 6-59 mo of age and how this and other evidence from the studies were used to redesign the health component of the program. Articles 4 and 5 present results of the development and pilot testing of the modified health component, the Integrated Strategy for Attention to Nutrition (abbreviated to EsIAN from its name in Spanish) (article 4), and the process and challenges of training and supervision in taking the EsIAN to scale (article 5). The final article provides reflections on the relevance of this body of work for implementation research in nutrition.
墨西哥的“进步条件现金转移计划”始于 1997 年,具有强有力的循证设计。该计划的最终目标是通过教育、健康和食品三个组成部分来促进人力资本的发展。严格的影响评估为该计划对多个结果产生的影响提供了证据,包括儿童生长情况,但也提出了一些方案设计和实施方面的挑战,这些挑战可能限制了影响的范围。本增刊的目的是介绍研究成果,这些研究导致了对健康部分的重新设计,在试点规模内实施和评估,并在全国范围内推广,这代表了评估人员、方案实施人员和资助者之间超过 15 年的合作。这些研究使用了各种方法,包括过程评估、队列研究、民族志评估和集群随机试验等。这些文章报告了以前未发表的结果和已发表文献的引用。第 1 篇文章使用影响途径来突出限制潜在更大影响的差距和瓶颈,正是对这些差距和瓶颈的最初认识,推动了这项长期合作。第 2 篇文章探讨了影响参与方案和采取方案所提议行动的社会和文化因素。第 3 篇文章介绍了一项实施的集群随机试验,旨在为孕妇和哺乳期妇女以及 6-59 月龄儿童选择营养补充剂提供信息,并介绍了如何利用这项研究和其他研究证据来重新设计该方案的健康部分。第 4 篇和第 5 篇文章介绍了修改后的健康部分的开发和试点测试的结果,即综合营养关注战略(EsIAN)(第 4 篇文章),以及将 EsIAN 推广到规模的培训和监督过程和挑战(第 5 篇文章)。最后一篇文章对这一系列工作对营养实施研究的相关性进行了反思。