Myszka Anna, Trzciński Dawid, Tomczyk Jacek
Institute of Biological Sciences, Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University, Wóycickiego 1/3 Street, 01-938 Warsaw, Poland.
Institute of Anthropology, Adam Mickiewicz University, Umultowska 89, 61-614 Poznań, Poland.
Anthropol Anz. 2020 Feb 13;77(1):47-56. doi: 10.1127/anthranz/2019/1004.
According to the "bone former" hypothesis, individuals may prone to new bone formation (osteophytes) in response to stress. Not many studies have addressed the bone formation conundrum, and previous findings are not unanimous. Determining the validity of the "bone former" concept is crucial for the reliable interpretation of osteophytes in past skeletal populations. This study set out to demonstrate that a relationship exists between vertebral and extravertebral osteophytes. The bone material used in the study came from the late medieval, early modern (14 to 16 century) population from Łekno (Poland), and included the skeletons of 188 adults (110 males, 56 females). Marginal osteophytes were scored in the shoulder, elbow, wrist, hip, knee and ankle. Vertebral osteophytes were analysed on the upper and lower margins of the vertebral body. The results showed that vertebral osteophytes were correlated with osteophytes in the shoulder ( = 0.578, = 0.003), elbow ( = 0.416, = 0.034), wrist ( = 0.619, = 0.001), hip ( = 0.411, = 0.024), and all the joints combined ( = 0.446, = 0.014). Significant relationships between vertebral and extravertebral osteophytes were noted in the female group. It can be claimed that individuals are predicted/or not to be bone formers but whether these bone changes occur depends on the individual lifespan.
根据“骨质增生者”假说,个体可能会因压力而易于形成新骨(骨赘)。针对骨质形成难题的研究并不多,且先前的研究结果并不一致。确定“骨质增生者”概念的有效性对于可靠解读过去骨骼人群中的骨赘至关重要。本研究旨在证明椎体骨赘与椎体外骨赘之间存在关联。该研究使用的骨材料来自波兰莱克诺中世纪晚期、近代早期(14至16世纪)的人群,包括188具成年人骨骼(110名男性,56名女性)。对肩部、肘部、腕部、髋部、膝部和踝部的边缘骨赘进行评分。对椎体的上下边缘进行椎体骨赘分析。结果表明,椎体骨赘与肩部骨赘(r = 0.578,p = 0.003)、肘部骨赘(r = 0.416,p = 0.034)、腕部骨赘(r = 0.619,p = 0.001)、髋部骨赘(r = 0.411,p = 0.024)以及所有关节的骨赘总和(r = 0.446,p = 0.014)均存在相关性。在女性组中,椎体骨赘与椎体外骨赘之间存在显著关联。可以认为,个体被预测为骨质增生者与否,但这些骨质变化是否发生取决于个体的寿命。