Engel Bettina, Esser Miriam, Bleckwenn Markus
Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg, Department für Versorgungsforschung, Abteilung Allgemeinmedizin, Oldenburg, Germany.
Rheinische Friedrich Wilhelm University, Bonn, Germany.
GMS J Med Educ. 2019 Nov 15;36(6):Doc71. doi: 10.3205/zma001279. eCollection 2019.
The present study investigates the feasibility of the application of evidence-based medicine (EBM) procedures by students as part of practical training in general medicine through a newly developed blended-learning teaching concept. This study describes the development, piloting and evaluation of a blended-learning concept for implementing EBM education as part of general practice training. Our concept consists of an online tutorial introducing the theoretical background, two classroom seminars for consolidation and practical exercises based on case studies. Following this, students were to apply their knowledge to real-life cases during their training. To evaluate the learning outcome, we have developed an evaluation tool based on the Fresno Test (Bonn Test). At the end of the seminar, students were invited to evaluate the concept. A total of 35 students took part in the feasibility study and 27 Bonn tests were evaluated. All students achieved more than the pass mark required in the Bonn Test in the preparation of clinical case studies. Because of the differentiated assessment of learning outcomes in all categories of the 5A EBM process, difficulties in the translation process can be revealed by the Bonn test. As a result, the concept can be refined and improved continuously. In the evaluation, 74% of the students rated the teaching concept "good" or "very good". Overall, this study confirmed the feasibility of our EBM concept while demonstrating that students are able to apply the theoretical knowledge acquired to real-life settings. Further research with our concept is needed, especially at an earlier stage in the curriculum.
本研究通过一种新开发的混合式学习教学理念,调查了医学生在普通医学实践培训中应用循证医学(EBM)程序的可行性。本研究描述了一种混合式学习理念的开发、试点和评估,该理念将循证医学教育作为全科医学培训的一部分。我们的理念包括一个介绍理论背景的在线教程、两个用于巩固的课堂研讨会以及基于案例研究的实践练习。在此之后,学生们要在培训期间将所学知识应用于实际案例。为了评估学习成果,我们基于弗雷斯诺测试(波恩测试)开发了一种评估工具。在研讨会结束时,邀请学生对该理念进行评估。共有35名学生参与了可行性研究,对27份波恩测试进行了评估。在临床案例研究的准备中,所有学生的成绩都超过了波恩测试要求的及格分数。由于在5A循证医学过程的所有类别中对学习成果进行了差异化评估,波恩测试可以揭示翻译过程中的困难。因此,该理念可以不断完善和改进。在评估中,74%的学生对教学理念的评价为“好”或“非常好”。总体而言,本研究证实了我们循证医学理念的可行性,同时表明学生能够将所学理论知识应用于实际场景。需要对我们的理念进行进一步研究,尤其是在课程的早期阶段。