Keppens Gil, Spruyt Bram, Dockx Jonas
Research Group TOR, Department of Sociology, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium.
Centre for Educational Effectiveness and Evaluation, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Front Psychol. 2019 Dec 3;10:2623. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02623. eCollection 2019.
In order to use attendance monitoring within an integrative strategy for preventing, assessing and addressing cases of youth with school absenteeism, we need to know whether the attendance data collected by schools cover all students with (emerging) school attendance problems (SAPs). The current article addresses this issue by comparing administrative attendance data collected by schools with self-reported attendance data from the same group of students (age 15-16) in Flanders, the Dutch-speaking part of Belgium ( = 4344). We seek to answer the following question: does an estimation of unauthorized absenteeism based on attendance data as collected by schools through electronic registration differ from self-reported unauthorized absenteeism and, if so, are the differences between administrative and self-reported unauthorized absenteeism systematic? Our results revealed a weak association between self-reported unauthorized school absenteeism and registered unauthorized school absenteeism. Boys, students in technical and vocational tracks and students who speak a foreign language at home, with a less-educated mother and who receive a school allowance, received more registered unauthorized absences than they reported themselves. In addition, pupils with school refusal and who were often authorized absent from school received more registered unauthorized absences compared to their self-reported unauthorized school absenteeism. In the discussion, we elaborate on the implications of our findings.
为了在预防、评估和处理学生旷课问题的综合策略中使用考勤监测,我们需要了解学校收集的考勤数据是否涵盖了所有存在(新出现的)出勤问题(SAPs)的学生。本文通过对比比利时弗拉芒地区(比利时讲荷兰语的部分)同一组学生(15 - 16岁, = 4344)的学校行政考勤数据与自我报告的考勤数据来解决这个问题。我们试图回答以下问题:基于学校通过电子注册收集的考勤数据对未经批准的旷课情况进行的估计,与自我报告的未经批准的旷课情况是否存在差异?如果存在差异,行政记录的和自我报告的未经批准的旷课情况之间的差异是否具有系统性?我们的研究结果显示,自我报告的未经批准的旷课情况与记录的未经批准的旷课情况之间存在微弱关联。男孩、技术和职业课程的学生、在家说外语、母亲受教育程度较低且领取学校津贴的学生,其记录的未经批准缺勤次数比他们自己报告的更多。此外,与自我报告的未经批准的旷课情况相比,有学校拒学问题且经常被批准缺课的学生记录的未经批准缺勤次数更多。在讨论部分,我们详细阐述了研究结果的意义。