Alliprandini Marina, Ferrandin Andressa, Fernandes Adriana, Belim Mariana, Jorge Mariana, Colombo Bruno, Yaguchi Jordana, Chung Thais, Jorge Amaury, Duarte Pericles
Hospital Universitario do Oeste do Parana, Cascavel, Parana, Brazil.
Hospital Sao Lucas - FAG, Cascavel, Parana, Brazil.
Anaesthesiol Intensive Ther. 2019;51(5):348-356. doi: 10.5114/ait.2019.91189.
The study was conducted to evaluate intensive care unit (ICU) patients that ultimately died but could have met criteria for end-of-life management/palliative care (ELM-PC), and to analyse the application of components of palliative care, either "unperformed procedures" or elements of "futile/unnecessary treatment".
An observational prospective cohort in five ICUs in Southern Brazil. Adult patients who died were evaluated, searching for criteria for ELM-PC. The correct application of nine preselected items by the ICU team was studied.
Among 253 admissions, 52 patients died; among these, 38.5% met criteria for ELM-PC. Among ELM-PC candidates (n = 20), the ELM-PC was started later (after day 3) in 60%, and only three patients received adequate palliative care. "Analgesia" and "daily family interviews" were the most correctly applied ELM-PC elements. "Terminal extubation/weaning" was not performed in any of the patients. A reduction in the lifespan from the onset of ELM-PC to death was observed in patients who underwent "correct" interventions - 66.6% died on the first day of ELM-PC.
In a patient cohort from a low-medium-income country, one-third of patients who died in the ICU had criteria (indications) for ELM-PC; however, the palliative care was adequately performed for only 15% of patients, with great heterogeneity and delays regarding its initiation.
本研究旨在评估最终死亡但可能符合临终管理/姑息治疗(ELM-PC)标准的重症监护病房(ICU)患者,并分析姑息治疗各组成部分的应用情况,即“未实施的操作”或“无效/不必要治疗”的要素。
在巴西南部的五个ICU中进行一项观察性前瞻性队列研究。对死亡的成年患者进行评估,寻找ELM-PC的标准。研究了ICU团队对九个预选项目的正确应用情况。
在253例入院患者中,52例死亡;其中,38.5%符合ELM-PC标准。在ELM-PC候选患者(n = 20)中,60%的患者在较晚时间(第3天之后)开始接受ELM-PC,只有三名患者接受了充分的姑息治疗。“镇痛”和“每日家庭访谈”是应用最正确的ELM-PC要素。所有患者均未进行“终末拔管/撤机”。在接受“正确”干预的患者中,观察到从开始ELM-PC到死亡的生存期缩短——66.6%的患者在ELM-PC的第一天死亡。
在一个中低收入国家的患者队列中,三分之一在ICU死亡的患者有ELM-PC标准(指征);然而,只有15%的患者得到了充分的姑息治疗,在启动方面存在很大的异质性和延迟。