Cantinotti Massimiliano, Giordano Raffaele, Koestenberger Martin, Voges Inga, Santoro Giuseppe, Franchi Eliana, Assanta Nadia, Valverde Israel, Simpson John, Kutty Shelby
Fondazione G. Monasterio CNR-Regione Toscana, Massa, Italy.
Department of Advanced Biomedical Sciences, Adult and Pediatric Cardiac Surgery, University of Naples Federico II, Naples, Italy.
Cardiol Young. 2020 Jan;30(1):1-11. doi: 10.1017/S1047951119003196. Epub 2020 Jan 8.
We reviewed the recent literature for echocardiographic assessment of mitral valve abnormalities in children. A literature search was performed within the National Library of Medicine using the keywords "mitral regurgitation and/or stenosis, children." The search was refined by adding the keywords "echocardiographic definition, classification, and evaluation." Thirty-one studies were finally included. Significant advances in echocardiographic imaging of mitral valve defects, mainly due to the implementation of three-dimensional technology, contribute to a better understanding of the underlying anatomy. However, heterogeneity between classification systems of mitral valve disease severity is a serious problem. For regurgitant lesions, there is only very limited evidence from small studies that support the adoption of quantitative/semi-quantitative indexes commonly employed in adults. Despite the lack of evidence base, qualitative evaluation of regurgitation severity is often employed. For stenotic lesions, no clear categorisation based on trans-valvular echocardiography-derived "gradients" has been consistently applied to define mild, moderate, or severe obstruction across different paediatric age ranges. Quantitative parameters such as valve area have also been poorly validated in children. Adult recommendations are frequently applied without validation for the paediatric age. In conclusion, significant advances in the anatomical evaluation of mitral valve diseases have been made, thanks to three-dimensional echocardiography; however, limitations remain in the quantitative/semi-quantitative estimation of disease severity, both with respect to valvular regurgitation and stenosis. Because adult echocardiographic recommendations should not be simply translated to the paediatric age, more specific paediatric guidelines and standards for the assessment of mitral valve diseases are needed.
我们回顾了近期有关儿童二尖瓣异常的超声心动图评估的文献。在美国国立医学图书馆进行了文献检索,使用关键词“二尖瓣反流和/或狭窄,儿童”。通过添加关键词“超声心动图定义、分类和评估”对检索进行了细化。最终纳入了31项研究。二尖瓣缺陷的超声心动图成像取得了重大进展,主要归功于三维技术的应用,这有助于更好地理解潜在的解剖结构。然而,二尖瓣疾病严重程度分类系统之间的异质性是一个严重问题。对于反流性病变,仅有来自小型研究的非常有限的证据支持采用成人常用的定量/半定量指标。尽管缺乏证据基础,但反流严重程度的定性评估仍经常被采用。对于狭窄性病变,基于经瓣膜超声心动图得出的“压力阶差”,尚无明确的分类被一致应用于界定不同儿童年龄范围内的轻度、中度或重度梗阻。诸如瓣膜面积等定量参数在儿童中也未得到充分验证。成人的建议经常未经儿童年龄验证就被应用。总之,由于三维超声心动图,二尖瓣疾病的解剖学评估取得了重大进展;然而,在疾病严重程度的定量/半定量评估方面,无论是瓣膜反流还是狭窄,仍然存在局限性。由于成人超声心动图建议不能简单地应用于儿童,因此需要更具体的儿童二尖瓣疾病评估指南和标准。