Serviço de Neurologia, Departamento de Neurociências, Hospital de Santo António, Centro Hospitalar Universitário do Porto, Largo do Prof. Abel Salazar, 4099-001 Porto, Portugal.
Instituto de Ciências Biomédicas Abel Salazar, Universidade do Porto, Rua Jorge de Viterbo Ferreira 228, 4050-313 Porto, Portugal.
Epilepsy Behav. 2020 Mar;104(Pt A):106886. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2019.106886. Epub 2020 Jan 11.
Patients with epilepsy have poor social outcome. Multifactorial factors are usually involved, but among them, stigma features may have an important role. Genetic generalized epilepsies (GGEs) were previously considered "benign" syndromes. The aim of our study was to assess social impairment and stigma in GGE and to evaluate differences between the following GGE subsyndromes: juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME), juvenile absence epilepsy (JAE), and generalized tonic-clonic seizures alone (GTCSA). Additionally, we compared these outcomes with outcomes from a cohort of patients with epilepsy with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy with hippocampal sclerosis (MTLE-HS), a severe and difficult-to-treat syndrome. Results were compared with social data from the general population.
Adult patients with epilepsy with a previously classified GGE or MTLE-HS were consecutively invited to fill in a sociodemographic and stigma questionnaire in outpatient clinic. Clinical data and psychiatric comorbidities were retrieved from clinical notes.
Questionnaires from 333 patients were obtained: 226/67% from patients with GGE (JME: 106/31.8%, GTCSA: 74/22.2%, and JAE: 46/13.8%) and 107/32.1% from patients with MTLE-HS. We found that patients with GGE have a good academic achievement but they have increased difficulties in finding a partner, higher rates of divorce, and a reduced number of children per woman and per man when compared with general population. We also observed that patients with GGE have higher rates of unemployment (22.6%) and lower monthly income than general population. Severe problems in housing were only seen in GGEs. Of these, 3 patients (1.3%) were in homeless condition. Over half (52%) of patients with MTLE-HS and over a quarter (28%) of patients with GGE experienced felt stigma. Psychiatric comorbidity was highly prevalent among GGE (34.1%), especially in patients with refractory epilepsy. Mood and anxiety disorders were the most prevalent conditions. No other significant differences were found between GGE subsyndromes.
We found an impairment in every social domain assessed (except in level of education) when compared with general population. Most of the social outcome parameters were unexpectedly close or similar to MTLE-HS or even worse as it was the prevalence of homelessness among GGE. Social impairment is underdiagnosed and might be considered in clinical practice even in syndromes for some time considered benign such as GGE.
癫痫患者的社会预后较差。通常涉及多种因素,但其中,耻辱感特征可能具有重要作用。遗传性全面性癫痫(GGE)以前被认为是“良性”综合征。我们研究的目的是评估 GGE 中的社会障碍和耻辱感,并评估以下 GGE 亚综合征之间的差异:青少年肌阵挛性癫痫(JME)、青少年失神癫痫(JAE)和单纯全面强直阵挛发作(GTCSA)。此外,我们将这些结果与内侧颞叶癫痫伴海马硬化(MTLE-HS)患者队列的结果进行了比较,MTLE-HS 是一种严重且难以治疗的综合征。结果与一般人群的社会数据进行了比较。
连续邀请在门诊就诊的患有以前分类为 GGE 或 MTLE-HS 的成年癫痫患者填写社会人口统计学和耻辱感问卷。从临床记录中检索临床数据和精神共病。
获得了 333 名患者的问卷:226/67%来自 GGE 患者(JME:106/31.8%,GTCSA:74/22.2%,JAE:46/13.8%)和 107/32.1%来自 MTLE-HS 患者。我们发现,与一般人群相比,GGE 患者的学业成绩较好,但在寻找伴侣、离婚率较高、女性和男性每人生育子女数量较少方面存在更多困难。我们还观察到,GGE 患者的失业率(22.6%)和月收入低于一般人群。只有 GGE 患者才会出现严重的住房问题。其中,有 3 名患者(1.3%)处于无家可归状态。超过一半(52%)的 MTLE-HS 患者和超过四分之一(28%)的 GGE 患者感到有耻辱感。GGE 中精神共病非常普遍(34.1%),尤其是在难治性癫痫患者中。心境和焦虑障碍是最常见的疾病。在 GGE 亚综合征之间没有发现其他显著差异。
与一般人群相比,我们发现每个社会领域的评估都存在障碍(除了教育水平)。大多数社会结局参数出人意料地接近或类似于 MTLE-HS,甚至比 GGE 中的无家可归现象更为严重。社会障碍被低估了,即使在某些时期被认为是良性的综合征(如 GGE),在临床实践中也可能被考虑在内。