National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, USA.
Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto, CA, USA.
J Air Waste Manag Assoc. 2020 Mar;70(3):283-291. doi: 10.1080/10962247.2020.1713249.
Exhaust flows from coal-fired electricity-generating plants are determined by averaging flue gas velocities measured at prescribed points in the stack cross section. These velocity measurements are made using EPA-approved differential pressure probes such as the 2-hole S-probe or the 5-hole spherical probe. Measurements using the more accurate 5-hole spherical probes require a time-consuming rotation (or nulling) of the probe to find the yaw angle. We developed a time-saving non-nulling technique using a spherical probe that measures all 3 components of velocity and therefore provides better accuracy than an S-probe. We compared the non-nulling technique with the EPA Method 2F nulling technique at both high (16 m/s) and low (7 m/s) loads in a coal-fired powerplant smokestack. Their excellent mutual agreement (within 0.3% of the flow) demonstrates that the non-nulling technique accurately measures flue gas flows.: Accurate flow measurements are critical for quantifying the levels of greenhouse gases emitted from coal-fired power plant smokestacks. Flow measurement accuracy derives from the annual calibration of stack flow monitors. Calibrations are performed using EPA sanctioned pitot traverse methods called the flow relative accuracy test audit (RATA). This study demonstrates the viability of a new pitot traverse method, herein called the Non-Nulling Method. Testing in a coal-fired power plant stack showed that the new method is 5 times faster to implement than the most accurate EPA pitot traverse method (i.e., Method 2F), yet gives the same or better accuracy.
燃煤电厂的排气流量是通过平均测量烟囱横截面上规定点的烟道气流速度来确定的。这些速度测量使用经 EPA 批准的压差探头进行,例如 2 孔 S 探头或 5 孔球形探头。使用更精确的 5 孔球形探头进行测量需要耗时旋转(或调零)探头以找到偏航角。我们开发了一种使用球形探头的省时非调零技术,该探头可以测量所有 3 个速度分量,因此比 S 探头具有更高的准确性。我们在燃煤电厂烟囱的高(16 m/s)和低(7 m/s)负荷下,将非调零技术与 EPA 方法 2F 调零技术进行了比较。它们的极好一致性(在流量的 0.3% 以内)表明,非调零技术可以准确测量烟道气流。:准确的流量测量对于量化燃煤电厂烟囱排放的温室气体水平至关重要。流量测量的准确性源自烟囱流量监测器的年度校准。校准使用 EPA 批准的皮托管横越方法(称为流量相对精度测试审核(RATA))进行。本研究证明了一种新的皮托管横越方法的可行性,在此称为非调零方法。在燃煤电厂烟囱中的测试表明,新方法的实施速度比最准确的 EPA 皮托管横越方法(即方法 2F)快 5 倍,但具有相同或更好的准确性。