Wirtz Markus Antonius, Schulz Anja
Institut für Alltagskultur, Bewegung und Gesundheit Fachrichtung Forschungsmethoden, Pädagogische Hochschule Freiburg.
Rehabilitation (Stuttg). 2020 Oct;59(5):303-314. doi: 10.1055/a-1064-6587. Epub 2020 Jan 21.
Rehabilitation is evidenced based if treatments are applied that proved to enhance rehabilitation outcomes - generally patients' health or participation- effectively in a causal manner. Randomized control trials (RCTs) allow determining the efficacy of treatments unambiguously. If alternative research designs (e. g. case-control studies, cohort studies, observational studies) are adopted, the association of the treatment and the improvement of the health status or participation may be biased by confounding variables (limitations of internal validity). Several variants of the basic RCT designs have been developed (e. g. cluster-randomized trials, factorial designs, pragmatic trials) to adapt RCTs to the demands of practical applications. Additionally, deciding and acting evidence-based requires rehabilitation treatments and recommendations which have been developed on a solid theoretical basis and which are applied in practical rehabilitation care appropriately. Especially, because treatments have to be chosen and provided according to rehabilitation patients' individual needs. Furthermore, in every day care the application of treatments has to be matched to the specific conditions of the respective rehabilitation institution. Thus, a comprehensive understanding of evidence requires not only efficacy studies adopting RCTs. Additionally, knowledge about treatment efficacy has to be complemented by studies investigating conceptual and theoretical foundations of effective treatments (intervention design) as well as studies to apply treatments in practical rehabilitation care (implementation research) appropriately.
如果所采用的治疗方法被证明能以因果关系有效地提高康复效果——通常是患者的健康状况或参与度,那么康复就是基于证据的。随机对照试验(RCT)能够明确确定治疗方法的疗效。如果采用其他研究设计(例如病例对照研究、队列研究、观察性研究),治疗与健康状况改善或参与度之间的关联可能会受到混杂变量的影响(内部效度的局限性)。已经开发了几种基本RCT设计的变体(例如整群随机试验、析因设计、务实试验),以使RCT适应实际应用的需求。此外,基于证据进行决策和行动需要在坚实的理论基础上制定并在实际康复护理中适当应用的康复治疗方法和建议。特别是因为必须根据康复患者的个体需求来选择和提供治疗方法。此外,在日常护理中,治疗方法的应用必须与各个康复机构的具体情况相匹配。因此,对证据的全面理解不仅需要采用RCT的疗效研究。此外,关于治疗疗效的知识还必须辅以研究有效治疗方法的概念和理论基础(干预设计)以及在实际康复护理中适当应用治疗方法的研究(实施研究)。