Foster Ida, Wyman Joshua, Tong Donia, Colwell Kevin, Talwar Victoria
Department of Educational and Counselling Psychology, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Department of Psychology, Southern Connecticut State University, New Haven, CT, USA.
Psychiatr Psychol Law. 2018 Oct 31;26(4):499-519. doi: 10.1080/13218719.2018.1507844. eCollection 2019.
This study examines how children's age, gender and interviewer gender affected children's testimony after witnessing a theft. Children ( = 127, age = 6-11 years) witnessed an experimenter (E1) find money, which he/she may/may not have taken. E1 then asked the children to falsely deny that the theft occurred, falsely accuse E1 of taking the money, or tell the truth when interviewed by a second experimenter. Falsely denying or falsely accusing influenced children's forthcomingness and quality of their testimony. When accusing, boys were significantly more willing than girls to disclose about the theft earlier and without being asked directly. When truthfully accusing, children gave lengthier testimony to same-gendered adults. When denying, children were significantly more willing to disclose the theft earlier to male interviewers than to females. As children aged, they were significantly less likely to lie, more likely to disclose earlier when accusing, and give lengthier and more consistent testimony.
本研究考察了儿童的年龄、性别及访谈者性别在目睹一起盗窃事件后对儿童证言的影响。儿童(n = 127,年龄6至11岁)目睹一名实验者(E1)找到钱,该实验者可能拿了钱,也可能没拿。随后E1要求儿童在接受第二名实验者访谈时,要么谎称盗窃未发生,要么诬告E1拿了钱,要么说出实情。谎称或诬告会影响儿童的坦率程度及其证言的质量。在进行诬告时,男孩比女孩明显更愿意更早地主动说出盗窃事件,而无需被直接询问。在如实进行指控时,儿童会向同性别的成年人提供更长的证言。在进行否认时,儿童明显更愿意向男性访谈者而非女性访谈者更早地说出盗窃事件。随着儿童年龄增长,他们说谎的可能性显著降低,在进行指控时更早说出实情的可能性增加,并且提供的证言更长、更连贯。