Department of Physical and Occupational Therapy, McGill University, Montréal, Canada.
Research Institute of the McGill University Health Centre, McGill University, Montréal, Canada.
Disabil Rehabil. 2021 Sep;43(19):2815-2827. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2020.1717649. Epub 2020 Jan 30.
We completed a scoping review to: (1) identify strategies that have been used to engage hard-to-reach populations in childhood disability research, and (2) synthesize information as to whether and how these strategies were evaluated.
Systematic search of six electronic databases and grey literature to identify articles published in the last 10 years. Studies published in English, French, and Spanish reporting on strategies used to engage hard-to-reach populations in childhood disability research were eligible for inclusion.
Out of 106 articles selected for full text review, 16 were included. Engagement was more common in earlier stages of research. The populations included in studies were children with disabilities and their parents. Engagement strategies were reported but rarely evaluated. Anecdotal outcomes of engagement were reported in 14/16 studies and included positive outcomes for the children and parents such as empowerment. The challenges with engagement included the increased time needed to engage children with disabilities or their parents.
Our results can guide others who wish to engage a diverse group of children with disabilities and their parents in research. Research on how to engage other hard-to-reach populations within the childhood disability umbrella and evaluation of engagement strategies and outcomes is needed.IMPLICATIONS FOR REHABILITATION• Service providers should be concerned when the research informing their practices does not include families that represent their clients (e.g., families who are low income, Indigenous, ethnic minority, or LGBTQI parents of children with disabilities).• Strategies used to include children with disabilities in research, such as offering varied response methods that include story telling or photography, may also be used to promote participation in clinical services.• Service providers and teachers may have a role in facilitating the recruitment of 'hard-to-reach' families in research and advising researchers on methods to create a comfortable environment with accessible means of data collection for children with disabilities.
我们进行了范围综述,以:(1)确定已用于招募残疾儿童研究中难以接触人群的策略,以及(2)综合有关这些策略是否以及如何进行评估的信息。
系统搜索六个电子数据库和灰色文献,以确定在过去 10 年中发表的文章。有资格纳入研究的文章为英文、法文和西班牙文出版,报告了用于招募残疾儿童研究中难以接触人群的策略。
在 106 篇全文审查中,有 16 篇被纳入。参与度在研究的早期阶段更为常见。研究中包括残疾儿童及其父母。报告了参与策略,但很少进行评估。14/16 项研究报告了参与的轶事结果,包括增强残疾儿童及其父母的权能等积极结果。参与面临的挑战包括需要更多时间来吸引残疾儿童或其父母。
我们的研究结果可以为希望招募不同残疾儿童及其父母参与研究的人提供指导。需要研究如何在残疾儿童保护伞内招募其他难以接触的人群,并评估参与策略和结果。
当为其客户提供服务的提供者的实践所依据的研究不包括代表其客户的家庭(例如,低收入、土著、少数民族或残疾儿童的 LGBTQI 父母的家庭)时,应引起关注。
用于招募残疾儿童参与研究的策略,例如提供包括讲故事或摄影在内的各种响应方法,也可用于促进参与临床服务。
服务提供者和教师可能在招募“难以接触”的家庭参与研究方面发挥作用,并为研究人员提供有关创建舒适环境和为残疾儿童提供可访问的数据收集方法的建议。