Reddy Vamsi, Gupta Arjun, White Michael D, Gupta Raghav, Agarwal Prateek, Prabhu Arpan V, Lieber Bryan, Chang Yue-Fang, Agarwal Nitin
1Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
2Department of Neurological Surgery, Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, Newark, New Jersey.
J Neurosurg. 2020 Jan 31;134(2):638-645. doi: 10.3171/2019.11.JNS192679. Print 2021 Feb 1.
OBJECTIVE: Publication metrics such as the Hirsch index (h-index) are often used to evaluate and compare research productivity in academia. The h-index is not a field-normalized statistic and can therefore be dependent on overall rates of publication and citation within specific fields. Thus, a metric that adjusts for this while measuring individual contributions would be preferable. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) has developed a new, field-normalized, article-level metric called the "relative citation ratio" (RCR) that can be used to more accurately compare author productivity between fields. The mean RCR is calculated as the total number of citations per year of a publication divided by the average field-specific citations per year, whereas the weighted RCR is the sum of all article-level RCR scores over an author's career. The present study was performed to determine how various factors, such as academic rank, career duration, a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degree, and sex, impact the RCR to analyze research productivity among academic neurosurgeons. METHODS: A retrospective data analysis was performed using the iCite database. All physician faculty affiliated with Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME)-accredited neurological surgery programs were eligible for analysis. Sex, career duration, academic rank, additional degrees, total publications, mean RCR, and weighted RCR were collected for each individual. Mean RCR and weighted RCR were compared between variables to assess patterns of analysis by using SAS software version 9.4. RESULTS: A total of 1687 neurosurgery faculty members from 125 institutions were included in the analysis. Advanced academic rank, longer career duration, and PhD acquisition were all associated with increased mean and weighted RCRs. Male sex was associated with having an increased weighted RCR but not an increased mean RCR score. Overall, neurological surgeons were highly productive, with a median RCR of 1.37 (IQR 0.93-1.97) and a median weighted RCR of 28.56 (IQR 7.99-85.65). CONCLUSIONS: The RCR and its derivatives are new metrics that help fill in the gaps of other indices for research output. Here, the authors found that advanced academic rank, longer career duration, and PhD acquisition were all associated with increased mean and weighted RCRs. Male sex was associated with having an increased weighted, but not mean, RCR score, most likely because of historically unequal opportunities for women within the field. Furthermore, the data showed that current academic neurosurgeons are exceptionally productive compared to both physicians in other specialties and the general scientific community.
目的:诸如赫希指数(h指数)等发表指标常被用于评估和比较学术界的研究生产力。h指数并非一个经领域标准化的统计量,因此可能依赖于特定领域内的总体发表率和引用率。所以,在衡量个人贡献时能对此进行调整的指标会更可取。美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)已开发出一种新的、经领域标准化的文章层面指标,称为“相对引用率”(RCR),它可用于更准确地比较不同领域作者的生产力。平均RCR的计算方法是某一出版物每年的总引用次数除以每年该领域特定的平均引用次数,而加权RCR是作者职业生涯中所有文章层面RCR分数的总和。本研究旨在确定学术职级、职业生涯时长、哲学博士(PhD)学位和性别等各种因素如何影响RCR,以分析学术神经外科医生的研究生产力。 方法:使用iCite数据库进行回顾性数据分析。所有隶属于研究生医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)认证的神经外科项目的医师教员均符合分析条件。收集了每个人的性别、职业生涯时长、学术职级、额外学位、总发表量、平均RCR和加权RCR。使用SAS软件9.4版本比较平均RCR和加权RCR之间的变量,以评估分析模式。 结果:分析纳入了来自125个机构的总共1687名神经外科教员。高级学术职级、更长的职业生涯时长和获得PhD学位均与平均RCR和加权RCR的增加相关。男性与加权RCR的增加相关,但与平均RCR分数的增加无关。总体而言,神经外科医生的生产力很高,RCR中位数为1.37(四分位距0.93 - 1.97),加权RCR中位数为28.56(四分位距7.99 - 85.65)。 结论:RCR及其衍生指标是有助于填补其他研究产出指标空白的新指标。在此,作者发现高级学术职级、更长的职业生涯时长和获得PhD学位均与平均RCR和加权RCR的增加相关。男性与加权RCR(而非平均RCR)分数的增加相关,这很可能是因为该领域历史上女性获得的机会不平等。此外,数据显示,与其他专科的医生和一般科学界相比,当前的学术神经外科医生生产力极高。
Orthop J Sports Med. 2023-1-20
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2025-1
J Am Acad Orthop Surg Glob Res Rev. 2024-2-1
J Am Acad Orthop Surg Glob Res Rev. 2023-7-1
Orthop J Sports Med. 2023-1-20
Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2022-11-16