Stevenson Mary O, Sineath R Craig, Haw J Sonya, Tangpricha Vin
Division of Endocrinology, Metabolism and Lipids, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
Atlanta VA Medical Center, Decatur, Georgia.
J Endocr Soc. 2019 Nov 18;4(1):bvz007. doi: 10.1210/jendso/bvz007. eCollection 2020 Jan 1.
Transgender and gender-nonconforming individuals have unique health care needs and have difficulty accessing health care services because of a lack of qualified health care providers, insurance coverage, mistreatment, and bias by the medical community. Medical trainees and physicians report a lack of education in, and exposure to, the clinical care and unique aspects of this field. We assessed the use of a standardized patient as a tool to evaluate 4 core medical competencies (patient care, medical knowledge, professionalism, and interpersonal communication) of endocrinology fellows at a single training program.
Endocrine fellows were evaluated by faculty in different aspects of transgender care and completed a self-assessment before and after the exercise. Faculty viewed the fellows during the Objective Clinical Structured Examination. Fellows were provided feedback by a faculty member and the standardized patient after the exercise.
Deficits were found in patient care and professionalism. Fellows scored well in medical knowledge. Fellows did not report an improvement in comfort and communication skills after the exercise. Interestingly, fellows' self-assessment scores in several domains declined after the standardized patient encounter, highlighting an occasion for self-reflection and growth within the realms of cultural competency and medical knowledge.
We conclude that use of standardized patients to teach medical competencies in transgender medicine may be one approach to improve exposure to, and training in, transgender medicine. Endocrine fellows still had discomfort treating transgender individuals after the standardized patient encounter and require other training activities that may include didactics and clinical case discussions.
跨性别和性别不一致的个体有独特的医疗保健需求,由于缺乏合格的医疗保健提供者、保险覆盖范围、虐待以及医学界的偏见,他们在获得医疗保健服务方面存在困难。医学实习生和医生表示,他们在该领域的临床护理及独特方面缺乏教育和接触。我们评估了使用标准化病人作为一种工具,来评估单一培训项目中内分泌科住院医师的4项核心医学能力(病人护理、医学知识、职业素养和人际沟通)。
内分泌科住院医师在跨性别护理的不同方面接受教员评估,并在练习前后完成自我评估。教员在客观临床结构化考试期间观察住院医师。练习结束后,教员和标准化病人为住院医师提供反馈。
在病人护理和职业素养方面发现了不足。住院医师在医学知识方面得分良好。练习后,住院医师并未报告在舒适度和沟通技巧方面有所改善。有趣的是,在与标准化病人接触后,住院医师在几个领域的自我评估分数下降,这凸显了在文化能力和医学知识领域进行自我反思和成长的契机。
我们得出结论,使用标准化病人来教授跨性别医学中的医学能力可能是一种增加对跨性别医学的接触和培训的方法。在与标准化病人接触后,内分泌科住院医师在治疗跨性别个体时仍感到不适,需要其他培训活动,可能包括教学和临床病例讨论。