School of Nursing and Midwifery, Queens University Belfast, Belfast, UK.
J Adv Nurs. 2020 May;76(5):1255-1265. doi: 10.1111/jan.14310. Epub 2020 Feb 25.
To determine what predicts health visitors' family-focused practice with mothers who have mental illness. To explore health visitors' experiences of family-focused practice and what factors, if any, enable and/or hinder it.
A sequential mixed-methods design was employed.
In Phase 1, a total of 230 health visitors, in five Health and Social Care Trusts in the UK were recruited using convenience sampling and completed the Family Focused Mental Health Practice Questionnaire. Three multiple regression models were developed to test whether workload (Model I), professional knowledge (Model II) and health visitors' professional and personal experience (Model III) predicted their family-focused practice. In Phase 2, 10 health visitors, who completed the questionnaire, participated in semi-structured interviews to describe their experiences of family-focused practice. The data collection of the two phases was conducted from September 2017 - September 2018.
Model III was significant. While personal experience of parenting was positively associated with family-focused practice, length registered as a health visitor and personal experience of mental illness was negatively associated. Qualitative findings suggested that increasing years of professional experience and personal experience of mental illness enabled health visitors to support mothers and their children, but not other adult family members, including partners. Limited skills and knowledge to support mothers with severe mental illness (i.e. schizophrenia) hindered family-focused practice.
This study advances understanding of how health visitors' professional and personal experiences can influence their family-focused practice and highlights the importance of organizations promoting their capacity to support mothers with severe mental illness and to include mothers' partners.
A clear understanding of factors affecting health visitors' capacity to engage in family-focused practice will help to inform policy, education and practice in health visiting; with potential to improve outcomes for the whole family.
确定哪些因素可以预测有精神疾病的母亲的健康访视员的以家庭为中心的实践。探讨健康访视员以家庭为中心的实践经验,以及有哪些因素(如果有的话)可以促进或以阻碍这种实践。
采用顺序混合方法设计。
在第一阶段,总共招募了英国五个卫生和社会保健信托机构的 230 名健康访视员,使用方便抽样法完成了以家庭为中心的心理健康实践问卷。开发了三个多元回归模型,以检验工作量(模型 I)、专业知识(模型 II)和健康访视员的专业和个人经验(模型 III)是否可以预测他们的以家庭为中心的实践。在第二阶段,完成问卷的 10 名健康访视员参加了半结构化访谈,以描述他们以家庭为中心的实践经验。两个阶段的数据收集时间为 2017 年 9 月至 2018 年 9 月。
模型 III 是显著的。虽然育儿的个人经验与以家庭为中心的实践呈正相关,但作为健康访视员的注册年限和个人精神疾病经历与以家庭为中心的实践呈负相关。定性研究结果表明,增加专业经验和个人精神疾病经历可以使健康访视员能够支持母亲及其子女,但不能支持其他成年家庭成员,包括伴侣。支持患有严重精神疾病(如精神分裂症)的母亲的技能和知识有限,阻碍了以家庭为中心的实践。
本研究增进了对健康访视员的专业和个人经验如何影响他们以家庭为中心的实践的理解,并强调了组织促进他们支持患有严重精神疾病的母亲和包括母亲伴侣的能力的重要性。
对影响健康访视员以家庭为中心实践能力的因素有清晰的了解,将有助于为健康访视的政策、教育和实践提供信息,有可能改善整个家庭的结果。