Aljethaily Abdulrahman, Al-Mutairi Turki, Al-Harbi Khalid, Al-Khonezan Saleh, Aljethaily Abdallah, Al-Homaidhi Hossam S
College of Medicine, Al-Imam University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Al-Yamamah Hospital (Ministry of Health), Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2020 Jan 6;11:1-8. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S228399. eCollection 2020.
To explore the pediatricians' attitudes and perceptions toward do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders in a specific region of the world not fully explored before.
A cross-sectional study was conducted between March 4 and May 30, 2018. Pediatricians from three public hospitals in the city of Riyadh were asked to respond to a questionnaire consisting of 22 questions designed to meet the objectives of our study.
A total of 203 pediatricians (51.2% female) completed the questionnaire, both junior pediatricians (JPs) and senior pediatricians (SPs). A majority (58.9% of JPs and 61.4% of SPs) thought patients have the right to demand intensive care, despite their terminal illness. Half the participants in both groups thought that DNR is a physician's decision. Only 9.3% of JPs and 12.5% of SPs felt comfortable discussing DNR with patients/families. Medical school was also a source of knowledge on DNR issues, mainly for JPs (40.2% of JPs vs 20.8% of SPs, =0.005). Half the participants felt that DNR is consistent with Islamic beliefs, while 57.9% of JPs vs 41.7% of SPs felt they are legally protected. Hospital policy was clear to 48.6% of JPs vs 66.7% of SPs, while procedure was clear to 35.5% of JPs vs 49% of SPs.
Several factors are present that may hinder DNR implementation, such as doubts concerning being legally protected, doubts concerning consistency with Islamic sharia, unclear policies and procedures, and lack of training and orientation on DNR issues. Policies may need to include patients as decision-makers.
在世界上一个此前未得到充分研究的特定地区,探讨儿科医生对不进行心肺复苏(DNR)医嘱的态度和看法。
于2018年3月4日至5月30日开展了一项横断面研究。利雅得市三家公立医院的儿科医生被要求回答一份包含22个问题的问卷,这些问题旨在实现我们的研究目标。
共有203名儿科医生(51.2%为女性)完成了问卷,包括初级儿科医生(JPs)和高级儿科医生(SPs)。大多数(58.9%的JPs和61.4%的SPs)认为,尽管患者身患绝症,但他们有权要求重症监护。两组中各有一半的参与者认为DNR是医生的决定。只有9.3%的JPs和12.5%的SPs愿意与患者/家属讨论DNR。医学院也是DNR问题的知识来源,主要针对JPs(40.2%的JPs vs 20.8%的SPs,P = 0.005)。一半的参与者认为DNR与伊斯兰信仰一致,而57.9%的JPs vs 41.7%的SPs认为他们受到法律保护。48.6%的JPs清楚医院政策,而66.7%的SPs清楚;35.5%的JPs清楚流程,而49%的SPs清楚。
存在若干可能阻碍DNR实施的因素,例如对法律保护的疑虑、对与伊斯兰教法一致性的疑虑、政策和流程不明确,以及在DNR问题上缺乏培训和指导。政策可能需要将患者纳入决策者范围。