Acute effects of different orthoses on lower extremity kinetics and kinematics during running; a musculoskeletal simulation analysis.

PURPOSE

The current investigation aimed to examine the effects of different orthotic conditions on the biomechanical mechanisms linked to the aetiology of chronic pathologies using musculoskeletal simulation.

METHODS

16 male and 20 females ran over an embedded force plate at 4.0 m/s, in five different conditions (medial, lateral, no-orthoses, semi-custom and off the shelf). Kinematics of the lower extremities were collected using an eight-camera motion capture system and lower extremity joint loading also explored using a musculoskeletal simulation approach. Differences between orthoses conditions were examined using 2 × 2 mixed ANOVA.

RESULTS

External instantaneous load rate was significantly reduced in the off the shelf orthoses (male = 1290.60 and female = 1567.10 N/kg/s), compared to the medial (male = 1480.45 and female = 1767.05 N/kg/s) and semi-custom (male = 1552.99 and female = 1704.37 N/kg/s) conditions. In addition, peak patellofemoral stress was significantly lower in the off the shelf orthoses (male = 68.55 and female = 94.91 KPa/kg) compared to the lateral condition (male = 70.49 and female = 103.22 KPa/kg). Finally, peak eversion angles were significantly attenuated in the medial orthoses (male = -6.61 and female = -7.72 deg) compared to the lateral (male = -9.61 and female = -10.32 deg), no-orthoses (male = -8.22 and female = -10.10 deg), semi-custom (male = -8.25 and female = -9.49 deg) and off the shelf (male = -7.54 and female = -8.85 deg) conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

The current investigation shows that different orthotic devices⁄ configurations may provide distinct benefits in terms of their effectiveness in attenuating the biomechanical parameters linked to the aetiology of chronic running injuries.