Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, United Kingdom.
Institute of Applied Health Research, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
Vaccine. 2020 Feb 28;38(10):2424-2432. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.12.009. Epub 2020 Feb 5.
Recent debates on the introduction of new childhood vaccines in the UK have suggested that 'peace of mind' (PoM) might influence decision making. The aim of this study is to ascertain the importance of 'PoM' in individuals' decision making.
Four focus groups were conducted in the UK. Participants were 22 females and 2 males, aged 18-74 years, with a selection of non-parents, parents, guardians and foster carers. Data were analysed using an inductive thematic framework approach and conceptualised using the Health Belief Model, which provided an overview of participants' perceptions and behaviours about childhood vaccinations.
Vaccine associated PoM was associated with individuals' perceptions of disease severity, with individuals feeling more reassurance after obtaining vaccinations against diseases that they considered to be severe compared to relatively mild diseases. Conversely, concerns about vaccination side-effects reduced participants PoM, but the duration of this effect varied between individuals. Other factors, such as social pressure and the emotional anxiety related to children's feelings, or physical reactions, to vaccinations also negatively impacted on participants' vaccine associated PoM.
Vaccine associated PoM was a consideration for some participants seeking vaccinations but was only a minor motivating factor for these individuals. These differences stemmed from whether participants received PoM from the uptake of a vaccination because they perceived some intrinsic benefit from it or, conversely, they considered vaccinations as a routine health intervention. Overall, vaccine related PoM varied between participants in magnitude and fluctuated over time, even in the same individuals.
最近英国关于引入新的儿童疫苗的争论表明,“安心”(PoM)可能会影响决策。本研究的目的是确定“PoM”在个体决策中的重要性。
在英国进行了 4 个焦点小组。参与者为 22 名女性和 2 名男性,年龄在 18-74 岁之间,包括一些非父母、父母、监护人以及寄养父母。使用归纳主题框架方法进行数据分析,并使用健康信念模型对其进行概念化,该模型概述了参与者对儿童疫苗接种的看法和行为。
与疫苗相关的 PoM 与个体对疾病严重程度的看法有关,与那些认为疾病严重的人相比,接种针对严重疾病的疫苗后,个体感到更加安心,而对于相对较轻的疾病则不然。相反,对疫苗副作用的担忧会降低参与者的 PoM,但这种影响的持续时间因人而异。其他因素,如社会压力和与孩子对疫苗的感觉或身体反应有关的情绪焦虑,也会对参与者的疫苗相关 PoM 产生负面影响。
与疫苗相关的 PoM 是一些寻求疫苗接种的参与者的考虑因素,但只是这些个体的次要激励因素。这些差异源于参与者是否因为从疫苗接种中获得了 PoM,因为他们认为从中获得了一些内在的好处,或者相反,他们认为疫苗接种是一种常规的健康干预。总体而言,疫苗相关的 PoM 在参与者之间的大小和波动时间上存在差异,甚至在同一参与者中也是如此。