Predicting chronic algal toxicity from 1- to 48-h pulsed exposures to mine site waters using time-averaged concentrations.

Despite concentrations often fluctuating in aquatic systems that receive contaminant inputs, there has only been a relatively small number of studies investigating the toxicity of intermittent exposures. This is particularly the case for industrial and mine effluents that may contain complex mixtures of contaminants and other stressors. The lack of information is impeding the regulation of such contaminant exposures, whose risk is often assessed by comparison to continuous exposures in whole effluent toxicity (direct toxicity assessment) testing. The current study compared the toxicity from continuous (72-h) and pulsed (1- to 48-h) exposures of two neutralised mine waters (NMWs) to the freshwater algae, Chlorella sp. When the algal toxicity of the different exposures was related to the time-averaged concentration (TAC) of contaminants, it was found that the TAC was a good predictor of toxicity in any given test, with variability in toxicity between tests mainly related to differences in contaminant concentrations from the neutralisation of the acidic mine waters. When the data from tests on two samples were combined on a whole-effluent TAC basis, the EC50 values (95% confidence intervals) for the continuous and pulsed exposures were 0.68% (0.36-1.3) and 0.63% (0.38-1.1) respectively, for NMW sample one, while the corresponding EC50 values for NMW sample two were 1.3% (1.0-1.7) and 1.9% (1.6-2.2), respectively. The toxicity of the second water was strongly influenced by the zinc, and probably copper, concentrations, while the toxicity of the first appeared to be related to additive or synergistic toxicity from Al, Cd, Mn and Pb. The findings are discussed in relation to using a contaminant TAC-approach to revise water quality guideline values derived for continuous exposures for application to pulsed exposures, where higher concentrations may be permissible for short durations.