Ay Pinar, Teker Ayse Gulsen, Hidiroglu Seyhan, Tepe Pinar, Surmen Aysen, Sili Uluhan, Korten Volkan, Karavus Melda
Department of Public Health, School of Medicine, Marmara University, Istanbul, Turkey.
Department of Infectious Diseases and Clinical Microbiology, School of Medicine, Marmara University, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Infect Dev Ctries. 2019 Feb 28;13(2):111-117. doi: 10.3855/jidc.10926.
Studies indicate that adherence to hand hygiene guidelines is at suboptimal levels. We aimed to explore the reasons for poor hand hygiene compliance.
A qualitative study based on the Theory of Planned Behavior as a framework in explaining compliance, consisting four focus group discussions and six in-depth interviews.
Participants mostly practiced hand hygiene depending on the sense of "dirtiness" and "cleanliness". Some of the participants indicated that on-job training delivered by the infection control team changed their perception of "emotionally" based hand hygiene to "indication" based. Direct observations and individual feedback on one-to-one basis were the core of this training. There was low social cohesiveness and a deep polarization between the professional groups that led one group accusing the other for not being compliant.
The infection control team should continue delivering one-to-one trainings based on observation and immediate feedback. But there is need to base this training model on a structured behavioral modification program and test its efficacy through a quasi-experimental design. Increasing social cohesiveness and transforming the blaming culture to a collaborative safety culture is also crucial to improve compliance. High workload, problems related to work-flow and turnover should be addressed.
研究表明,对手卫生指南的依从性处于不理想水平。我们旨在探究手卫生依从性差的原因。
一项基于计划行为理论的定性研究,该理论作为解释依从性的框架,包括四次焦点小组讨论和六次深入访谈。
参与者大多根据“脏污感”和“清洁感”来进行手卫生。一些参与者表示,感染控制团队提供的在职培训将他们基于“情感”的手卫生观念转变为基于“指征”的观念。直接观察和一对一的个人反馈是此次培训的核心。社会凝聚力较低,专业群体之间存在严重两极分化,导致一个群体指责另一个群体不遵守规定。
感染控制团队应继续基于观察和即时反馈提供一对一培训。但需要将此培训模式建立在结构化行为改变计划的基础上,并通过准实验设计测试其效果。增强社会凝聚力并将指责文化转变为协作安全文化对于提高依从性也至关重要。应解决高工作量、与工作流程和人员流动相关的问题。