Department of Medical Humanities, Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute, Amsterdam UMC (location VUmc), Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Mulier Institute, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Child Care Health Dev. 2020 May;46(3):369-380. doi: 10.1111/cch.12760. Epub 2020 Feb 13.
Although healthcare professionals often consider body weight a sensitive and difficult topic to discuss with children, a contextualized and comprehensive understanding of youth perspectives on weight-related words used in healthcare has yet to be established. This qualitative study aims to explore perspectives of Dutch children on the terminology healthcare professionals use when discussing weight.
Fourteen interviews and one focus group discussion were held with children (age 8-16) who were in care because of their weight. A toolkit with customizable interview techniques was used in order to facilitate reflection and tailor the interview to each respondent. A narrative content analysis was conducted.
Respondents attached both clear and subtle differences in meanings to (certain) weight-related words. Their perspectives were not unanimous for any single word. Moreover, at times, respondents framed certain words in positive or negative ways or used a word they disliked to describe themselves. This illustrates that meanings of weight-related words are not fixed but context and situation specific.
This study revealed that meanings children assign to weight-related words are shaped by their experiences in the broader social context, especially at school, as well as with (previous) healthcare professionals. It pointed towards the importance of bedside manner, acquaintanceship, and support. Healthcare professionals treating children because of their body weight are advised to invest in a good patient-caregiver relationship, pay attention to children's previous (negative) social weight-related experiences, and reflect critically on their own preconceptions about body weight and the impact these preconceptions might have on their patient-caregiver relationships.
尽管医疗保健专业人员通常认为体重是一个敏感且难以与儿童讨论的话题,但对于青少年对医疗保健中与体重相关的词汇的看法,尚未形成一个具有上下文和全面的理解。本定性研究旨在探讨荷兰儿童对医疗保健专业人员在讨论体重时使用的术语的看法。
对因体重问题而接受护理的 8-16 岁儿童进行了 14 次访谈和一次焦点小组讨论。使用了带有可定制访谈技术的工具包,以促进反思并根据每个受访者的情况调整访谈。进行了叙述性内容分析。
受访者对(某些)与体重相关的词汇赋予了明确和微妙的差异。对于任何一个特定的词汇,他们的观点并不一致。此外,有时受访者以积极或消极的方式来描述某些词汇,或者使用他们不喜欢的词汇来描述自己。这表明与体重相关的词汇的含义不是固定的,而是具体取决于上下文和情境。
本研究表明,儿童赋予与体重相关的词汇的含义是由他们在更广泛的社会背景下的经历塑造的,尤其是在学校,以及与(以前的)医疗保健专业人员的经历。这表明了医患关系、熟悉程度和支持的重要性。建议治疗因体重问题而接受治疗的儿童的医疗保健专业人员投资于良好的医患关系,关注儿童以前的(负面)与体重相关的社会经历,并批判性地反思自己对体重的固有观念以及这些观念对医患关系可能产生的影响。