Furukawa Mitsuru, Kamata Michihiro, Kuramoto Tetsuya, Takeuchi Yoshinori, Kawabata Soya
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Shizuoka City Shimizu Hospital, Shizuoka, Japan.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Keiyu Hospital, Kanagawa, Japan.
Spine Surg Relat Res. 2019 Sep 4;4(1):23-30. doi: 10.22603/ssrr.2019-0040. eCollection 2020.
In drop finger, the extension of the finger is limited, although the wrist can be flexed dorsally. There have been no well-organized reports on drop finger pattern caused by cervical nerve root disorder. Moreover, diagnosis and treatment are delayed because of the inability to distinguish cervical radiculopathy from peripheral nerve disease. This study aimed to clarify the operative outcome of microscopic cervical foraminotomy (MCF) for cervical radiculopathy presenting drop finger and to investigate whether our classification based on drop finger patterns is useful retrospectively.
Overall, 22 patients with drop finger who underwent MCF were included. Grip power (GP) and longitudinal manual muscle test (MMT) score of each finger were examined. Drop finger patterns were classified as types I, II, and III. In type I, the extension disorders of the middle and ring fingers are severe and those of index and little fingers are mild. In type II, the extension disorders are severe from the little finger and slightly to index finger. In type III, the extension disorder is consistently severe in all fingers. Perioperative nerve root disorder and paralysis degree were investigated for all types.
The mean GP was significantly postoperatively improved in all 22 patients. The mean MMT score would benefit from exact data for almost all muscles, except the abductor pollicis brevis at the last follow-up. However, pre- and postoperative paralyses were severe in type III patients. C7 nerve root disorder was confirmed in 5/6 type I patients and C8 nerve root disorder in 12/13 type II and 3/3 type III patients.
The operative results of MCF were relatively good, except in type III patients. As a certain tendency was confirmed between the drop finger types and injured nerve roots, our classification may be useful in reducing misdiagnosis and improving the operative results to some extent.
在垂指畸形中,手指伸展受限,尽管手腕可背屈。关于由颈神经根疾病引起的垂指畸形模式,目前尚无系统的报道。此外,由于无法区分颈椎病与周围神经疾病,导致诊断和治疗延迟。本研究旨在阐明显微镜下颈椎椎间孔切开术(MCF)治疗表现为垂指畸形的颈椎病的手术效果,并回顾性研究基于垂指畸形模式的分类是否有用。
共纳入22例行MCF治疗的垂指畸形患者。检查各手指的握力(GP)和纵向徒手肌力试验(MMT)评分。垂指畸形模式分为I型、II型和III型。I型中,中指和环指伸展障碍严重,示指和小指伸展障碍轻微。II型中,从小指到示指伸展障碍逐渐严重。III型中,所有手指伸展障碍均持续严重。对所有类型患者的围手术期神经根疾病和麻痹程度进行研究。
22例患者术后平均GP均显著改善。除末次随访时拇短展肌外,几乎所有肌肉的平均MMT评分若有确切数据将更有意义。然而,III型患者术前和术后麻痹均严重。6例I型患者中有5例确诊为C7神经根疾病,13例II型患者中有12例、3例III型患者中有3例确诊为C8神经根疾病。
除III型患者外,MCF的手术效果相对较好。由于垂指畸形类型与受损神经根之间存在一定趋势,我们的分类可能有助于减少误诊,并在一定程度上改善手术效果。