Ado Muhammad Rabiu
Department of Chemical Engineering, College of Engineering, King Faisal University, P.O. Box 380, Al-Ahsa 31982, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
ACS Omega. 2020 Jan 22;5(4):1938-1948. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.9b03661. eCollection 2020 Feb 4.
While simulating toe-to-heel air injection (THAI), which is a variant of conventional in situ combustion that uses a horizontal producer well to recover mobilized partially upgraded heavy oil, the chemical kinetics is one of the main sources of uncertainty because the hydrocarbon must be represented by the use of oil pseudo-components. There is, however, no study comparing the predictive capability of the different kinetics schemes used to simulate the THAI process. From the literature, it was determined that the thermal cracking kinetics schemes can be broadly divided into two: split and direct conversion schemes. Unlike the former, the latter does not depend on the selected stoichiometric coefficients of the products. It is concluded that by using a direct conversion scheme, the extent of uncertainty imposed by the kinetics is reduced as the stoichiometric coefficients of the products are known with certainty. Three models, P, G, and B, each with their own different kinetics schemes, were successfully validated against a three-dimensional combustion cell experiment. In models P and G, which do not take low-temperature oxidation (LTO) into account, the effect of oil pseudo-component combustion reactions is insignificant. For model B, which included LTO reactions, LTO was also found to be insignificant because only a small fraction of oxygen bypassed the combustion front and the combustion zone was maintained at temperatures of over 600°C. Therefore, in all the models, it is observed that coke deposition was due to the thermal cracking taking place ahead of the combustion zone. During the first phase of the combustion, peak temperature curves of models P, G, and B closely matched the experimental curve, albeit with some deviations by up to 100°C between 90 and 120 min. After the increase in the air injection flux, only the model P curve overlapped the experimental curve. The model P cumulative oil production curve deviated from the experimental one by only a relative error of 4.0% compared to deviations in models G and B by relative errors of 6.0 and 8.3%, respectively. Consequently, it follows that model P provided better predictions of the peak temperature and cumulative oil production. The same conclusion can be drawn with regard to the produced oxygen concentration and combustion front velocity. With regard to American Petroleum Institute (API) gravity, it is found that all the three models predicted very similar trends to the experiment, just like in the case of the oil production rate curves, and therefore, no model, in these two cases, can be singled out as the best. Also, all the models' predictions of the produced CO concentration prior to the increase in the air flux closely match the experimental curve. There are, however, serious differences, especially by model P, from the reported experimental curve by up to 15% after the increase in the air flux.
在模拟从趾端到跟端空气注入法(THAI)时,该方法是常规就地燃烧的一种变体,利用水平生产井来采收被驱替的部分升级稠油,化学动力学是不确定性的主要来源之一,因为必须使用油类虚拟组分来表征碳氢化合物。然而,尚无研究比较用于模拟THAI过程的不同动力学方案的预测能力。从文献中可知,热裂解动力学方案大致可分为两类:裂化和直接转化方案。与前者不同,后者不依赖于所选产物的化学计量系数。得出的结论是,通过使用直接转化方案,由于产物的化学计量系数是确定已知的,因此动力学带来的不确定性程度会降低。三个模型P、G和B,每个都有其不同的动力学方案,已成功通过三维燃烧池实验进行了验证。在不考虑低温氧化(LTO)的模型P和G中,油类虚拟组分燃烧反应的影响微不足道。对于包含LTO反应的模型B,也发现LTO影响不大,因为只有一小部分氧气绕过燃烧前沿,且燃烧区温度保持在600℃以上。因此,在所有模型中,观察到焦炭沉积是由于在燃烧区前方发生的热裂解所致。在燃烧的第一阶段,模型P、G和B的峰值温度曲线与实验曲线紧密匹配,尽管在90至120分钟之间存在高达100℃的偏差。空气注入通量增加后,只有模型P的曲线与实验曲线重叠。模型P的累积产油量曲线与实验曲线的偏差仅为4.0%的相对误差,而模型G和B的偏差分别为6.0%和8.3%的相对误差。因此,可以得出模型P对峰值温度和累积产油量的预测更好。对于产出氧气浓度和燃烧前沿速度也可得出相同结论。关于美国石油学会(API)重度,发现所有三个模型预测的趋势与实验非常相似,就像产油率曲线的情况一样,因此,在这两种情况下,没有一个模型可以被选为最佳模型。此外,所有模型在空气通量增加之前对产出CO浓度的预测与实验曲线紧密匹配。然而,空气通量增加后,特别是模型P与报告的实验曲线存在高达15%的严重差异。