Liu Lunxu, Mei Jiandong, He Jie, Demmy Todd L, Gao Shugeng, Li Shanqing, He Jianxing, Liu Yang, Huang Yunchao, Xu Shidong, Hu Jian, Chen Liang, Zhu Yuming, Luo Qingquan, Mao Weimin, Tan Qunyou, Chen Chun, Li Xiaofei, Zhang Zhu, Jiang Gening, Xu Lin, Zhang Lanjun, Fu Jianhua, Li Hui, Wang Qun, Liu Deruo, Tan Lijie, Zhou Qinghua, Fu Xiangning, Jiang Zhongmin, Chen Haiquan, Fang Wentao, Zhang Xun, Li Yin, Tong Ti, Yu Zhentao, Liu Yongyu, Zhi Xiuyi, Yan Tiansheng, Zhang Xingyi, Pu Qiang, Che Guowei, Lin Yidan, Ma Lin, Embun Raul, Aragón Javier, Evman Serdar, Kocher Gregor J, Bertolaccini Luca, Brunelli Alessandro, Gonzalez-Rivas Diego, Dunning Joel, Liu Hui-Ping, Swanson Scott J, Borisovich Ryabov Andrey, Sarkaria Inderpal S, Sihoe Alan Dart Loon, Nagayasu Takeshi, Miyazaki Takuro, Chida Masayuki, Kohno Tadasu, Thirugnanam Agasthian, Soukiasian Harmic J, Onaitis Mark W, Liu Chia-Chuan
Department of Thoracic Surgery, West China Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China.
Department of Thoracic Surgery, National Cancer Center/National Clinical Research Center for Cancer/Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing 100021, China.
Ann Transl Med. 2019 Dec;7(23):712. doi: 10.21037/atm.2019.11.142.
Intraoperative bleeding is the most crucial safety concern of video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) for a major pulmonary resection. Despite the advances in surgical techniques and devices, intraoperative bleeding is still not rare and remains the most common and potentially fatal cause of conversion from VATS to open thoracotomy. Therefore, to guide the clinical practice of VATS lung surgery, we proposed the International Interest Group on Bleeding during VATS Lung Surgery with 65 experts from 10 countries in the field to develop this consensus document. The consensus was developed based on the literature reports and expert experience from different countries. The causes and incidence of intraoperative bleeding were summarised first. Seven situations of intraoperative bleeding were collected based on clinical practice, including the bleeding from massive vessel injuries, bronchial arteries, vessel stumps, and bronchial stumps, lung parenchyma, lymph nodes, incisions, and the chest wall. The technical consensus for the management of intraoperative bleeding was achieved on these seven surgical situations by six rounds of repeated revision. Following expert consensus statements were achieved: (I) Bleeding from major vascular injuries: direct compression with suction, retracted lung, or rolled gauze is useful for bleeding control. The size and location of the vascular laceration are evaluated to decide whether the bleeding can be stopped by direct compression or by ligation. If suturing is needed, the suction-compressing angiorrhaphy technique (SCAT) is recommended. Timely conversion to thoracotomy with direct compression is required if the operator lacks experience in thoracoscopic angiorrhaphy. (II) Bronchial artery bleeding: pre-emptive clipping of bronchial artery before bronchial dissection or lymph node dissection can reduce the incidence of bleeding. Bronchial artery bleeding can be stopped by compression with the suction tip, followed by the handling of the vascular stump with energy devices or clips. (III) Bleeding from large vessel stumps and bronchial stumps: bronchial stump bleeding mostly comes from accompanying bronchial artery, which can be clipped for hemostasis. Compression for hemostasis is usually effective for bleeding at the vascular stump. Otherwise, additional use of hemostatic materials, re-staple or a suture may be necessary. (IV) Bleeding from the lung parenchyma: coagulation hemostasis is the first choice. For wounds with visible air leakage or an insufficient hemostatic effect of coagulation, suturing may be necessary. (V) Bleeding during lymph node dissection: non-grasping en-bloc lymph node dissection is recommended for the nourishing vessels of the lymph node are addressed first with this technique. If bleeding occurs at the site of lymph node dissection, energy devices can be used for hemostasis, sometimes in combination with hemostatic materials. (VI) Bleeding from chest wall incisions: the chest wall incision(s) should always be made along the upper edge of the rib(s), with good hemostasis layer by layer. Recheck the incision for hemostasis before closing the chest is recommended. (VII) Internal chest wall bleeding: it can usually be managed with electrocoagulation. For diffuse capillary bleeding with the undefined bleeding site, compression of the wound with gauze may be helpful.
术中出血是电视辅助胸腔镜手术(VATS)进行肺大部切除术时最关键的安全问题。尽管手术技术和器械有所进步,但术中出血仍不罕见,仍是VATS转为开胸手术最常见且可能致命的原因。因此,为指导VATS肺手术的临床实践,我们联合该领域来自10个国家的65位专家成立了VATS肺手术出血国际兴趣小组,以制定本共识文件。该共识基于不同国家的文献报道和专家经验制定。首先总结了术中出血的原因和发生率。根据临床实践收集了七种术中出血情况,包括大血管损伤出血、支气管动脉出血、血管残端出血、支气管残端出血、肺实质出血、淋巴结出血、切口出血和胸壁出血。通过六轮反复修订,就这七种手术情况达成了术中出血管理的技术共识。达成了以下专家共识声明:(I)大血管损伤出血:用吸引器、牵拉肺组织或卷状纱布直接压迫有助于控制出血。评估血管裂伤的大小和位置,以决定出血能否通过直接压迫或结扎止血。如需缝合,推荐采用吸引压迫血管缝合技术(SCAT)。如果术者缺乏胸腔镜血管缝合经验,应及时转为开胸手术并直接压迫止血。(II)支气管动脉出血:在支气管或淋巴结清扫术前先行支气管动脉夹闭可降低出血发生率。支气管动脉出血可先用吸引器头压迫止血,随后用能量器械或夹子处理血管残端。(III)大血管残端和支气管残端出血:支气管残端出血大多来自伴行的支气管动脉,可予以夹闭止血。血管残端出血通常压迫止血有效。否则,可能需要额外使用止血材料、再次使用吻合器或缝合。(IV)肺实质出血:凝血止血是首选。对于有明显漏气或凝血止血效果不佳的伤口,可能需要缝合。(V)淋巴结清扫术中出血:推荐采用非抓持整块淋巴结清扫术,因为该技术可先处理淋巴结的滋养血管。如果在淋巴结清扫部位发生出血,可使用能量器械止血,有时可联合止血材料。(VI)胸壁切口出血:胸壁切口应始终沿肋骨上缘进行,逐层做好止血。建议在关胸前行切口止血复查。(VII)胸壁内部出血:通常可用电凝处理。对于出血部位不明确的弥漫性毛细血管出血,用纱布压迫伤口可能有帮助。