Glasgow Caledonian University - London, London, UK.
School of Health and Community Studies, Faculty of Health and Social Sciences, Leeds Beckett University, Leeds, UK.
Health Soc Care Community. 2020 Jul;28(4):1261-1269. doi: 10.1111/hsc.12959. Epub 2020 Feb 11.
Social capital, and more particularly the social networks that define its existence, is said to benefit health and well-being. In individuals recovering from alcohol and drug addiction, social capital accruing from social networks support treatment, recovery and maintenance. Therefore, the concept of social capital is important for public health practitioners working in recovery interventions. This qualitative study seeks to explore what practitioners perceive as the importance of social capital and how they apply the concept in interventions to support individuals recovering from drug and alcohol addiction. Eight public health practitioners involved in drug and substance abuse interventions in West Yorkshire, England, were interviewed. The results of the interview were then deductively coded using two priori themes of perceived impact of social capital on health outcomes and application of social capital theory in recovery interventions. The findings reveal that practitioners understand the impact of social capital as the effects of social networks on recovery and apply the concept in their interventions. However, the nature of interventions created based on similarities in condition (alcohol and substance addiction) and intended outcome (recovery) create bonding social capital with mixed outcomes. This paper argues that the wider benefits to service users are unintentionally inhibited by the overwhelming downsides of bonding social capital. For instance, closed support groups comprised of individuals with high similarities further exclude the already socioeconomically deprived service users from integrating and accessing resources outside their groups.
社会资本,尤其是构成其存在的社交网络,据称有益于健康和幸福。在酒精和药物成瘾后康复的个体中,社交网络积累的社会资本有助于治疗、康复和维持。因此,对于从事康复干预的公共卫生从业者来说,社会资本的概念很重要。这项定性研究旨在探讨从业者认为社会资本的重要性是什么,以及他们如何在干预措施中应用这一概念来支持药物和酒精成瘾的康复。采访了英格兰西约克郡参与药物和物质滥用干预的 8 名公共卫生从业者。然后,使用社会资本对健康结果的影响和社会资本理论在康复干预中的应用这两个先验主题,对访谈结果进行演绎编码。研究结果表明,从业者理解社会资本的影响是社交网络对康复的影响,并将这一概念应用于他们的干预措施中。然而,基于相似条件(酒精和物质成瘾)和预期结果(康复)创建的干预措施会产生混合结果的结合型社会资本。本文认为,由于结合型社会资本的压倒性负面影响,服务使用者的更广泛利益无意中受到了抑制。例如,由高度相似的个体组成的封闭支持小组进一步将已经处于社会经济劣势的服务使用者排除在其群体之外,无法融入和获取群体之外的资源。