Engelhardt Melina, Picht Thomas
Department of Neurosurgery, Charité Universitatsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Einstein Center for Neurosciences, Charité Universitatsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
J Neurol Surg A Cent Eur Neurosurg. 2020 Mar;81(2):147-154. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1701624. Epub 2020 Feb 11.
Neuronavigated repetitive transcranial stimulation (rTMS) at a frequency of 1 Hz was shown to reduce excitability in underlying brain areas while increasing excitability in the opposite hemisphere. In stroke patients, this principle is used to normalize activity between the lesioned and healthy hemispheres and to facilitate rehabilitation. However, standardization is lacking in applied protocols, and there is a poor understanding of the underlying physiologic mechanisms. Furthermore, the influence of hemispheric dominance on the intervention has not been studied before. A systematic evaluation of the effects in healthy subjects would deepen the understanding of these mechanisms and offer insights into ways to improve the intervention.
Twenty healthy subjects underwent five 15-minute sessions of neuronavigated rTMS or sham stimulation over their dominant or nondominant motor cortex. Dominance was assessed with the Edinburgh Handedness Inventory. Changes in both hemispheres were measured using behavioral parameters (finger tapping, grip force, and finger dexterity) and TMS measures (resting motor threshold, recruitment curve, motor area, and cortical silent period).
All subjects tolerated the stimulation well. A pronounced improvement was noted in finger tapping scores over the nonstimulated hemisphere as well as a nonsignificant reduction of the cortical silent period in the stimulated hemisphere, indicating a differential effect of the rTMS on both hemispheres. Grip force remained at the baseline level in the rTMS group while decreasing in the sham group, suggesting the rTMS counterbalanced the effects of fatigue. Lastly, dominance did not influence any of the observed effects.
This study shows the capability of the applied low-frequency rTMS protocol to modify excitability of underlying brain areas as well as the contralateral hemisphere. It also highlights the need for a better understanding of underlying mechanisms and the identification of predictors for responsiveness to rTMS. However, results should be interpreted with caution because of the small sample size.
研究表明,以1赫兹频率进行的神经导航重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)可降低大脑深层区域的兴奋性,同时增加对侧半球的兴奋性。在中风患者中,这一原理被用于使受损半球和健康半球之间的活动正常化,并促进康复。然而,应用方案缺乏标准化,对潜在生理机制的了解也不足。此外,半球优势对干预的影响此前尚未得到研究。对健康受试者的效应进行系统评估将加深对这些机制的理解,并为改善干预措施提供思路。
20名健康受试者在其优势或非优势运动皮层接受了5次每次15分钟的神经导航rTMS或假刺激。使用爱丁堡利手量表评估利手情况。通过行为参数(手指敲击、握力和手指灵活性)和TMS测量指标(静息运动阈值、募集曲线、运动区和皮质静息期)来测量两侧半球的变化。
所有受试者对刺激耐受性良好。未受刺激半球的手指敲击分数有显著改善,同时受刺激半球的皮质静息期有不显著的缩短,这表明rTMS对两侧半球有不同的影响。rTMS组的握力保持在基线水平,而假刺激组的握力下降,这表明rTMS抵消了疲劳的影响。最后,半球优势并未影响任何观察到的效应。
本研究表明,所应用的低频rTMS方案能够改变大脑深层区域以及对侧半球的兴奋性。它还强调了需要更好地理解潜在机制,并确定rTMS反应性的预测指标。然而,由于样本量较小,结果应谨慎解释。