Mitrofanov Ruslan
Ludwig-Maximilian University, Germany.
Hist Psychiatry. 2020 Jun;31(2):194-207. doi: 10.1177/0957154X20901648. Epub 2020 Feb 12.
Previous historiography has already paid particular attention to well-known 'metropolitan' biographies of I. Balinsky, V. Bekhterev and others, as well as their role in the establishment of a scientific approach in the treatment of mental illnesses in the Russian Empire. Little attention has been paid to 'provincial' physicians and the importance of their scientific activity in bridging the gap between the Russian and European institutions of psychiatry. The primary aim of this article is to show how Alexander Frese's 'mobile' and 'imperial' career influenced the emergence of the transnational origins of Russian psychiatry. It describes his travels to foreign psychiatric hospitals, and his subsequent critical assessment of them. I argue that his ideas, which had been formulated during these trips, determined the design of emerging psychiatric institutions (district hospitals) in the Russian Empire.
以往的史学研究已经特别关注了伊·巴林斯基、弗·别赫捷列夫等人广为人知的“大都市”传记,以及他们在俄罗斯帝国建立精神疾病科学治疗方法中所起的作用。而“外省”医生及其科学活动在弥合俄罗斯与欧洲精神病学机构之间差距方面的重要性却很少受到关注。本文的主要目的是展示亚历山大·弗雷泽“流动”且“帝国式”的职业生涯如何影响了俄罗斯精神病学跨国起源的出现。文章描述了他前往国外精神病院的经历,以及他随后对这些医院的批判性评估。我认为,他在这些旅行中形成的想法决定了俄罗斯帝国新兴精神病学机构(地区医院)的设计。