Scott C S, Greig L M, Brock D M, Hunt D D, Shaad D C, Carline J D
Division of Research in Medical Education, University of Washington, School of Medicine, Seattle 98195.
Med Educ. 1988 Sep;22(5):389-92. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.1988.tb00772.x.
This study assessed whether overall academic performance in undergraduate medical coursework can be predicted with reasonable accuracy by using grades from initial college-level courses rather than total premedical grade point averages (GPAs). Initial college grades from four areas, MCAT scores, and NBME I and II scores were recorded for students admitted to the University of Washington Medical School, for students admitted to other medical schools, and for students not admitted to any medical school. The results documented a high relationship between cumulative GPAs and initial grades, with differences found between those students admitted to medical school and those not admitted. The importance of this study is the documentation that little predictive utility is gained by waiting for overall college GPAs from medical school applicants. Initial GPAs are available 2 years earlier than overall GPAs and provide virtually the same information. Exploratory suggestions for medical school admission policies are made.
本研究评估了通过本科医学课程的初始大学水平课程成绩而非医学预科总平均绩点(GPA),是否能以合理的准确性预测整体学业表现。记录了华盛顿大学医学院录取的学生、其他医学院录取的学生以及未被任何医学院录取的学生在四个领域的初始大学成绩、医学院入学考试(MCAT)成绩以及美国国家医学考试委员会(NBME)第一次和第二次考试成绩。结果表明累积GPA与初始成绩之间存在高度关联,且医学院录取学生与未录取学生之间存在差异。本研究的重要性在于证明了等待医学院申请者的大学总GPA几乎没有预测价值。初始GPA比总GPA早两年可得,且提供了几乎相同的信息。文中还对医学院录取政策提出了探索性建议。