Department of General Practice, Western Sydney University, Campbelltown, Australia.
Department of Medical Education, Western Sydney University, Campbelltown, Australia.
Teach Learn Med. 2020 Jun-Jul;32(3):259-270. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2020.1715804. Epub 2020 Feb 17.
Correctional health services can provide quality learning experiences for medical students and graduate medical trainees, including through motivating learners to work with people involved with the justice system, and promoting understanding of the social determinants of health. We conducted 38 semi-structured interviews to examine the views of learners and educators on how to promote high quality clinical learning in correctional settings, with a focus on the Australian context. Participants included medical students; general practitioners who had undertaken graduate trainee placements; clinical staff involved in teaching and clinical supervision; and graduate program medical educators and university teachers from Australia, New Zealand, and Canada. Data were analyzed thematically. Clinical placements in correctional settings provided learning about the health of people involved in the justice system, but also beneficial clinical learning for working with a wide range of patients with complex health needs. Valued learnings included managing complex consultations, mental health and substance use disorders, and overcoming anxiety related to interacting with people in prison. Learner concerns included limited patient contact time, apprehension prior to placements, and stress related to experiences during the placements. This apprehension and stress could be mitigated by orientation and debriefing, and by appreciating healthcare professionals in correctional settings as advocates for their patients. Clinical supervision was perceived to be demanding in this context. Independent patient interaction was not usually possible for students and there could be short windows of time in which to provide direct patient care, making pauses for teaching difficult. Clinical placements in correctional health services provide experiential learning of direct relevance to medical student, and potentially to general practice trainee, curricula which is valuable even when learners do not have particular interest in correctional health. Furthermore, these placements may increase the capacity of the medical workforce to provide skilled care to other underserved populations. High quality learner and clinical supervisor experiences, and program scale and sustainability, require enhanced learning support systems through partnerships between correctional health services and education institutions. Required supports for learners include orientation to security arrangements, debriefing sessions which assist learners to distill their learning and to reflect on challenging experiences, and alternative learning opportunities for when direct patient consultations are not accessible. Supervisor teaching supports include shared teaching approaches in the correctional health clinics and added student support from university-based staff.
惩教卫生服务可为医学生和研究生提供高质量的学习体验,包括激励学习者与司法系统相关人员合作,并促进对健康的社会决定因素的理解。我们进行了 38 次半结构化访谈,以研究学习者和教育者对如何在惩教环境中促进高质量临床学习的看法,重点是澳大利亚的情况。参与者包括医学生;接受过研究生实习的全科医生;参与教学和临床监督的临床工作人员;以及来自澳大利亚、新西兰和加拿大的研究生项目医学教育者和大学教师。数据进行了主题分析。在惩教场所进行的临床实习提供了与参与司法系统的人的健康相关的学习,但也为与具有复杂健康需求的广泛患者进行有益的临床学习提供了机会。有价值的学习包括管理复杂的咨询、心理健康和物质使用障碍,以及克服与监狱中的人互动时的焦虑。学习者关注的问题包括接触患者的时间有限、实习前的焦虑以及实习期间的压力。通过定向和汇报以及欣赏惩教场所的医疗保健专业人员是患者的倡导者,可以减轻这种焦虑和压力。在这种情况下,临床监督被认为是具有挑战性的。学生通常无法独立与患者互动,并且可能只有很短的时间窗口来提供直接的患者护理,因此很难暂停教学。在惩教卫生服务中进行临床实习为医学生和可能的全科实习医生提供了与课程直接相关的体验式学习,即使学习者对惩教卫生没有特别的兴趣,这种学习也是有价值的。此外,这些实习可能会增加医疗保健人员为其他服务不足的人群提供熟练护理的能力。高质量的学习者和临床监督者的体验、计划规模和可持续性,需要通过惩教卫生服务和教育机构之间的伙伴关系来增强学习支持系统。学习者需要的支持包括对安全安排的定向、帮助学习者提炼学习内容并反思具有挑战性的经验的汇报会议,以及在无法进行直接患者咨询时的替代学习机会。监督者教学支持包括在惩教保健诊所中采用共同的教学方法和来自大学工作人员的额外学生支持。