J Am Heart Assoc. 2020 Feb 18;9(4):e014519. doi: 10.1161/JAHA.119.014519.
After becoming aware that the study in the above-referenced article did not fully account for certain information in the Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health [PATH] Wave 1 survey, the editors of reviewed the peer review process. During peer review, the reviewers identified the important question of whether the myocardial infarctions occurred before or after the respondents initiated e-cigarette use, and requested that the authors use additional data in the PATH codebook (age of first MI and age of first e-cigarettes use) to address this concern. While the authors did provide some additional analysis, the reviewers and editors did not confirm that the authors had both understood and complied with the request prior to acceptance of the article for publication. Post publication, the editors requested Dr. Bhatta et al conduct the analysis based on when specific respondents started using e-cigarettes, which required ongoing access to the restricted use dataset from the PATH Wave 1 survey. The authors agreed to comply with the editors' request. The deadline set by the editors for completion of the revised analysis was not met because the authors are currently unable to access the PATH database. Given these issues, the editors are concerned that the study conclusion is unreliable. The editors hereby retract the article from publication in . [original article URL: https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/JAHA.119.012317] Reference 1. Bhatta DN, Glantz SA. Electronic Cigarette Use and Myocardial Infarction Among Adults in the US Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health. . 2019;8:e012317. DOI: 10.1161/JAHA.119.012317.
在意识到上述文章中的研究未充分考虑《烟草与健康人口评估》(PATH)第一轮调查中的某些信息后,《[期刊名称]》的编辑们审查了同行评审过程。在同行评审期间,评审人员提出了一个重要问题,即心肌梗死是在受访者开始使用电子烟之前还是之后发生的,并要求作者使用PATH编码手册中的额外数据(首次心肌梗死的年龄和首次使用电子烟的年龄)来解决这一问题。虽然作者确实提供了一些额外分析,但在文章被接受发表之前,评审人员和编辑并未确认作者是否理解并遵守了该要求。发表后,编辑要求巴塔博士等人根据特定受访者开始使用电子烟的时间进行分析,这需要持续访问PATH第一轮调查的受限使用数据集。作者同意遵守编辑的要求。由于作者目前无法访问PATH数据库,编辑设定的完成修订分析的最后期限未能达到。鉴于这些问题,编辑们担心该研究结论不可靠。编辑特此撤回该文章在《[期刊名称]》上的发表。[原文链接:https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/JAHA.119.012317] 参考文献1. 巴塔DN,格兰茨SA。美国烟草与健康人口评估中成年人使用电子烟与心肌梗死。《[期刊名称]》。2019;8:e012317。DOI:10.1161/JAHA.119.012317。