Li L L, Zhao Y J, Chen H, Wang Y, Sun Y C
Center of Digital Dentistry, Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology & National Clinical Research Center for Oral Diseases & National Engineering Laboratory for Digital and Material Technology of Stomatology & Beijing Key Laboratory of Digital Stomatology, Beijing 100081, China.
Beijing Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2020 Feb 18;52(1):138-143. doi: 10.19723/j.issn.1671-167X.2020.01.022.
To evaluate the three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction accuracy of the intercuspal occlusion (ICO) of the dental casts, by the dental articulator position method, and provide a reference for clinical application.
The standard dental casts in ICO were mounted on average values articulator, and five pairs of milling resin cylinders were respectively attached to the base of both the casts. 100 μm articulating paper and occlusal record silicone rubber were used to detect the occlusal contact number between the posterior teeth of casts mounted on articulator in ICO. The occlusal contact numbers NA detected by the two methods were calculated simultaneously, as the reference. After the upper and lower casts were scanned separately, and the buccal data of casts in ICO were scanned with the aid of the dental articulator position, registration was carried out utilizing the registration software. Then the digital casts mounted in ICO as well as the buccal occlusal data were saved in standard tessellation language (STL) format. Geomagic Studio 2013 software was used to analyze the contact number NS between digital upper and lower casts by the "deviation analysis" function. The differences were compared between N and N, to evaluate the sensitivity and positive predict value (PPV) of the model scanner to reproduce the occlusal contact with the aid of dental articulator position. The distance D between the centers of the circles at the top surface of the upper and lower corresponding cylinders was obtained by the three-coordinate measuring system Faro Edge, as the reference value. The Geomagic Studio 2013 software was used to construct the cylinders of digital casts and the distance D between the centers of the circles at the top surface of the corresponding cylinders were measured, as the test value. The one-sample T test was used to analyze the variable differences between D and D.
The PPV of reproducing the occlusal contact point was 0.76 and sensitivity was 0.81. The distance error of the opposite cylinder was (0.232±0.089) mm. There was no statistical difference between the feature points 5-5', while there were statistical differences between the other feature points.
By the dental articulator position method, the model scanner reproduces the occlusal contact point with high sensitivity and PPV, and that meets clinical needs. Meanwhile, the distance between the feature points is greater than the reference value, which will lead to occlusal disturbance, and require clinical grinding.
采用牙合架定位法评估模型牙尖交错牙合(ICO)的三维(3D)重建精度,为临床应用提供参考。
将处于ICO的标准模型牙安装在平均值牙合架上,在上下颌模型底座分别粘贴五对研磨树脂柱。使用100μm咬合纸和咬合记录硅橡胶检测处于ICO的牙合架上模型后牙的咬合接触点数。同时计算两种方法检测到的咬合接触点数NA作为参考。分别对上下颌模型进行扫描,并借助牙合架定位扫描模型ICO时的颊面数据,利用配准软件进行配准。然后将处于ICO的数字化模型及颊面咬合数据保存为标准三角形网格语言(STL)格式。使用Geomagic Studio 2013软件通过“偏差分析”功能分析数字化上下颌模型间的接触点数NS。比较NS与NA的差异,评估模型扫描仪借助牙合架定位再现咬合接触的敏感度和阳性预测值(PPV)。通过三坐标测量系统Faro Edge获取上下对应柱体顶面圆心之间的距离D作为参考值。使用Geomagic Studio 2013软件构建数字化模型的柱体并测量对应柱体顶面圆心之间的距离D作为测试值。采用单样本T检验分析D与D之间的变量差异。
再现咬合接触点的PPV为0.76,敏感度为0.81。相对柱体的距离误差为(0.232±0.089)mm。5-5′特征点之间无统计学差异,其他特征点之间有统计学差异。
采用牙合架定位法,模型扫描仪再现咬合接触点具有较高的敏感度和PPV,满足临床需求。同时,特征点间距离大于参考值,会导致咬合干扰,需进行临床调磨。