Wang G S, Xu L, Chen H T, Shi L P, Huang M J, Xi L, Xu L S, Wang F, Li H Y, Li S, Zhang Y J, Tan S Y, Hong R T, Lyu N H, Ye M, Gan H T, Liu M, Wu B Y
Department of Gastroenterology, The Second Medical Center of PLA General Hospital, Beijing 100853, China.
Department of Gastroenterology, Beijing Hospital, Beijing 100730, China.
Zhonghua Nei Ke Za Zhi. 2020 Feb 1;59(2):117-123. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0578-1426.2020.02.005.
To evaluate the efficacy and safety of Oryz-Aspergillus enzyme and pancreatin tablets (Combizym(®)) in the treatment of postprandial distress syndrome (PDS) in the elderly, compared with gastrointestinal motility drugs. A prospective randomized controlled trial was designed and registered in the China Clinical Trials Registry (ChiCTR-IPR-16008185). The elderly patients with PDS were randomly divided into three groups, including Mosapride group with Mosapride citrate tablets 5 mg 3 times per day for 2 weeks; Combizym(®) group with Combizym tablets 244 mg 3 times per day for 2 weeks; combined treatment group with both drugs and same doses for 2 weeks. The modified Nepean dyspepsia index (NDSI) score, discomfort intensity score and PDS score were calculated on patients before treatment, at the end of first and second week of treatment, as well as 4 weeks after treatment finished, respectively. Adverse effects were evaluated. A total of 323 patients from 16 tertiary hospitals in China were enrolled in this study. Among them, 105 patients were in Mosapride group, 109 in Combizym(®) group and 109 in combined treatment group. There were 148 males (45.8%) and 175 females (54.2%) with median age 71.4±9.0 years (60-100 years). Baseline characteristics of three groups were comparable. After treatment, the NDSI scores in three groups all decreased significantly (0.001), while they were similar between groups (0.05). The discomfort intensity score and PDS score in three groups showed a significant reduction after treatment (0.001), especially in the combined treatment group. Compared with Mosapride group, the scores in Combizym(®) group decreased significantly after one or two weeks [discomfort intensity score: after one week, 4.0(2.5, 8.0) vs. 6.0(3.0, 10.0); after two weeks, 3.0(0.0, 5.0) vs. 4.0(2.0, 6.0); all 0.05. PDS score: after one week, 6.0(3.0, 9.0) vs. 7.0(3.5, 10.5); after two weeks, 3.0(0.0, 5.0) vs. 4.0(2.0, 7.0); all 0.05]. The efficacy rate in all patients after first week of treatment was over 15.0%. The efficacy rates after two weeks were 55.2%, 68.8% and 73.4% in Mosapride group, Combizym(®) group and combined treatment group, respectively. After two week treatment, the efficacy rates in Combizym(®) group (0.041) and combined group (0.006) were higher than that of Mosapride group. The recurrence rate of Mosapride group was 9.5%, which was significantly higher than that of Combizym(®) group (1.8%, 0.05) and combined treatment group (1.8%, 0.05). There were no serious adverse effects in the three groups. The efficacy of Oryz-Aspergillus enzyme and pancreatin tablets is comparable with that of Mosapride in elderly PDS patients, with fewer adverse effects and low recurrence rate. Combination regimen indicates better efficacy than that of Oryz-Aspergillus enzyme and pancreatin tablets or Mosapride alone.
为评估米曲霉酶和胰酶片(慷彼申(®))治疗老年餐后不适综合征(PDS)的疗效及安全性,并与胃肠动力药物进行比较。设计了一项前瞻性随机对照试验,并在中国临床试验注册中心(ChiCTR-IPR-16008185)进行了注册。将老年PDS患者随机分为三组,包括莫沙必利组,给予枸橼酸莫沙必利片5 mg,每日3次,共2周;慷彼申(®)组,给予慷彼申片244 mg,每日3次,共2周;联合治疗组,两种药物均给予相同剂量,共2周。分别在治疗前、治疗第1周和第2周结束时以及治疗结束后4周计算患者的改良纽卡斯尔消化不良指数(NDSI)评分、不适强度评分和PDS评分。评估不良反应。本研究共纳入中国16家三级医院的323例患者。其中,莫沙必利组105例,慷彼申(®)组109例,联合治疗组109例。男性148例(45.8%),女性175例(54.2%),中位年龄71.4±9.0岁(60 - 100岁)。三组的基线特征具有可比性。治疗后,三组的NDSI评分均显著降低(P<0.001),但组间相似(P>0.05)。三组的不适强度评分和PDS评分在治疗后均显著降低(P<0.001),尤其是联合治疗组。与莫沙必利组相比,慷彼申(®)组在治疗1周或2周后的评分显著降低[不适强度评分:治疗1周后,4.0(2.5,8.0)对6.0(3.0,10.0);治疗2周后,3.0(0.0,5.0)对4.0(2.0,6.0);均P<0.05。PDS评分:治疗1周后,6.0(3.0,9.0)对7.0(3.5,10.5);治疗2周后,3.0(0.0,5.0)对4.0(2.0,7.0);均P<0.05]。治疗第1周后所有患者的有效率超过15.0%。莫沙必利组、慷彼申(®)组和联合治疗组治疗2周后的有效率分别为55.2%、68.8%和73.4%。治疗2周后,慷彼申(®)组(P = 0.041)和联合组(P = 0.006)的有效率高于莫沙必利组。莫沙必利组的复发率为9.5%,显著高于慷彼申(®)组(1.8%,P<0.05)和联合治疗组(1.8%,P<0.05)。三组均无严重不良反应。米曲霉酶和胰酶片在老年PDS患者中的疗效与莫沙必利相当,不良反应较少,复发率低。联合用药方案的疗效优于单独使用米曲霉酶和胰酶片或莫沙必利。