Rexand-Galais Franck, Le Goff Johane
BePsyLab and Spaces and Societies Research Team, Department of Psychology, University of Angers, Angers, France.
Lucien Hussel Hospital, Vienne and Psychopathology and Clinical Psychology Research Centre, Lumière University Lyon 2, Lyon, France.
Front Psychol. 2020 Jan 31;11:113. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.00113. eCollection 2020.
Claude Balier's narcissistic theory of ageing may be one of the pillars of French psycho-gerontology, but it is certainly not set in stone. On closer inspection, instead of being just minor variations on the same theme, the three stages of its development are structured around different references and make different assumptions. Some even contradict each other. Balier's theory nevertheless finds unity in its non-involutionary view of ageing. Narcissism and narcissistic destiny are given a central role, thus calling into question the notion that the paradigmatic function of transference neurosis can account for neurosis in old age. For more than 40 years, Balier's innovative notions have been the subject of many and sometimes divergent extensions in French psycho-gerontology.
克洛德·巴利耶的自恋型衰老理论或许是法国心理老年学的支柱之一,但它绝非一成不变。仔细审视会发现,其发展的三个阶段并非只是同一主题的细微变化,而是围绕不同的参照构建,有着不同的假设。有些甚至相互矛盾。然而,巴利耶的理论在其非退化性的衰老观点中找到了统一性。自恋及自恋命运被赋予核心地位,从而对移情神经症的范式功能能够解释老年期神经症这一观念提出了质疑。四十多年来,巴利耶的创新观念一直是法国心理老年学中诸多且有时存在分歧的拓展研究的主题。