Sederer L
Am J Psychiatry. 1977 Mar;134(3):267-72. doi: 10.1176/ajp.134.3.267.
The author reviews the history of moral therapy and the lessons and warnings it holds for modern psychiatry. Custodial management replaced moral therapy in this country in the late 1800s because of inadequate manpower and fiscal resources, a lack of charismatic leaders, the increasing lack of control over admissions and discharge, and other factors. One "solution" to the unacceptable conditions of custodial care was an increased faith in science and technology; humanistic medical science became scientism, and patients suffered. Morale is essential to the provision of moral therapy, and the increasing emphasis on somatic therapies has strained the union of morale and moral treatment. The author believes that the profession can reaffirm its identity and distinguish itself through the appropriate provision of humane, psychosocial care--the essence of moral therapy.
作者回顾了道德治疗的历史以及它给现代精神病学带来的经验教训和警示。由于人力和财政资源不足、缺乏有魅力的领导者、对入院和出院的控制日益缺乏以及其他因素,19世纪后期,监护管理在这个国家取代了道德治疗。对监护护理不可接受状况的一个“解决方案”是对科学技术的信心增强;人文医学科学变成了科学主义,患者因此受苦。士气对于提供道德治疗至关重要,而对躯体治疗的日益强调削弱了士气与道德治疗的结合。作者认为,该行业可以通过适当提供人道的社会心理护理——道德治疗的本质——来重申其身份并脱颖而出。