Comparison of three different methods of anterior tibial tendon transfer for relapsed clubfoot: A pilot study.

INTRODUCTION

The commonly techniques for anterior tibial tendon transfer (ATTT) for clubfoot are split transfers (Hoffer), whole transfers to cuboid (Garceau) or 3rd cuneiform (Ponseti). We compared these surgical ATTT methods for relapsed clubfoot.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Thirty relapsed clubfoot (46 feet) patients initially treated with Ponseti casting technique were prospectively randomized for ATTT techniques. The outcome was evaluated in terms of foot inversion, eversion and ankle dorsiflexion.

RESULTS

Average follow up was 5.49 months. Whole transfers had better absolute ankle dorsiflexion than split transfers. Foot inversion was comparable in Hoffer and Ponseti transfers but better with Garceau transfers. For eversion, best values occurred with Ponseti transfers. Absolute values of ankle dorsiflexion, foot inversion and eversion obtained with spilt transfers were less than those obtained with whole transfers (statistically insignificant).

CONCLUSIONS

No significant differences for foot or ankle function could be detected in this study using the various surgical ATTT techniques in short term follow up.