Kaale Aingaya J, Rutabasibwa Nicephorus, Mchome Laurent Lemeri, Lillehei Kevin O, Honce Justin M, Kahamba Joseph, Ormond D Ryan
1Division of Neurosurgery, Muhimbili Orthopaedic and Neurosurgical Institute, Muhimbili University of Health and Allied Sciences, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania; and.
Departments of2Neurosurgery and.
J Neurosurg. 2020 Feb 28;134(2):630-637. doi: 10.3171/2019.12.JNS192851. Print 2021 Feb 1.
Neuronavigation has become a crucial tool in the surgical management of CNS pathology in higher-income countries, but has yet to be implemented in most low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) due to cost constraints. In these resource-limited settings, neurosurgeons typically rely on their understanding of neuroanatomy and preoperative imaging to help guide them through a particular operation, making surgery more challenging for the surgeon and a higher risk for the patient. Alternatives to assist the surgeon improve the safety and efficacy of neurosurgery are important for the expansion of subspecialty neurosurgery in LMICs. A low-cost and efficacious alternative may be the use of intraoperative neurosurgical ultrasound. The authors analyze the preliminary results of the introduction of intraoperative ultrasound in an LMIC setting.
After a training program in intraoperative ultrasound including courses conducted in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, and Aurora, Colorado, neurosurgeons at the Muhimbili Orthopaedic and Neurosurgical Institute began its independent use. The initial experience is reported from the first 24 prospective cases in which intraoperative ultrasound was used. When possible, ultrasound findings were recorded and compared with postoperative imaging findings in order to establish accuracy of intraoperative interpretation.
Of 24 cases of intraoperative ultrasound that were reported, 29.2% were spine surgeries and 70.8% were cranial. The majority were tumor cases (95.8%). Lesions were identified through the dura mater in all 24 cases, with 20.8% requiring extension of craniotomy or laminectomy due to inadequate exposure. Postoperative imaging (typically CT) was only performed in 11 cases, but all 11 matched the findings on post-dural closure ultrasound.
The use of intraoperative ultrasound, which is affordable and available locally, is changing neurosurgical care in Tanzania. Ultimately, expanding the use of intraoperative B-mode ultrasound in Tanzania and other LMICs may help improve neurosurgical care in these countries in an affordable manner.
在高收入国家,神经导航已成为中枢神经系统疾病外科治疗中的关键工具,但由于成本限制,在大多数低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs)尚未得到应用。在这些资源有限的环境中,神经外科医生通常依靠对神经解剖学的理解和术前影像学检查来指导特定手术,这使得手术对医生来说更具挑战性,对患者来说风险更高。辅助外科医生提高神经外科手术安全性和有效性的替代方法对于在LMICs中扩大神经外科亚专业至关重要。一种低成本且有效的替代方法可能是使用术中神经外科超声。作者分析了在LMIC环境中引入术中超声的初步结果。
在包括在坦桑尼亚达累斯萨拉姆和科罗拉多州奥罗拉举办的课程在内的术中超声培训项目之后,穆希姆比利骨科和神经外科研究所的神经外科医生开始独立使用术中超声。报告了前24例使用术中超声的前瞻性病例的初步经验。尽可能记录超声检查结果并与术后影像学检查结果进行比较,以确定术中解读的准确性。
在报告的24例术中超声病例中,29.2%为脊柱手术,70.8%为颅脑手术。大多数是肿瘤病例(95.8%)。在所有24例病例中均通过硬脑膜识别出病变,20.8%因暴露不足需要扩大开颅术或椎板切除术。仅11例进行了术后影像学检查(通常为CT),但所有11例的结果均与硬脑膜关闭后超声检查结果相符。
使用价格低廉且当地可获取的术中超声正在改变坦桑尼亚的神经外科护理。最终,在坦桑尼亚和其他LMICs扩大术中B超的使用可能有助于以可承受的方式改善这些国家的神经外科护理。