Cosgrove Lisa, Morrill Zenobia, Yusif Michelangela, Vaswani Akansha, Cathcart Sadie, Troeger Rebecca, Karter Justin M
Department of Counseling and School Psychology, University of Massachusetts Boston, Boston, MA, United States.
Front Psychiatry. 2020 Feb 13;11:17. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.00017. eCollection 2020.
Children in the United States and internationally are increasingly being diagnosed with depression and related psychiatric conditions and a recent study found that antidepressant (ADM) use in children and adolescents rose substantially in youth cohorts in five Western countries from 2005 to 2012. However, there has been ongoing controversy over the effectiveness and safety of ADM use in children, including concerns about ADM increasing suicidality and self-harm. In addition to the increase in the diagnosis of depression, commercially driven off-label prescriptions have been cited as a significant reason for high rates of pediatric ADM prescribing. In this commentary, we discuss two drivers of the overuse of ADM, both of which are products of an increasingly medicalized approach to mental health: 1) the demand for mental health and depression screening in youth, despite the lack of evidence to support it, and 2) the renewed momentum of the Global Mental Health Movement and concomitant calls to "scale up" the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness. Using the lens of institutional corruption, we identify the ways in which both guild and financial conflicts of interest create obstacles to rational prescribing practices in pediatric populations and offer suggestions for reform.
美国以及国际上的儿童被诊断出患有抑郁症和相关精神疾病的情况日益增多。最近一项研究发现,2005年至2012年期间,五个西方国家的儿童和青少年群体中抗抑郁药(ADM)的使用大幅增加。然而,关于在儿童中使用ADM的有效性和安全性一直存在争议,包括担心ADM会增加自杀倾向和自我伤害行为。除了抑郁症诊断增加外,商业驱动的非标签处方被认为是儿科ADM高处方率的一个重要原因。在这篇评论中,我们讨论了ADM过度使用的两个驱动因素,这两个因素都是心理健康医疗化程度日益提高的产物:1)尽管缺乏证据支持,但对青少年心理健康和抑郁症筛查的需求;2)全球心理健康运动的新势头以及随之而来的“扩大”精神疾病诊断和治疗的呼声。我们从机构腐败的角度,确定了专业团体和经济利益冲突在哪些方面给儿科人群的合理处方实践造成了障碍,并提出了改革建议。