Herrera Diaz Mariana, Haworth-Brockman Margaret, Keynan Yoav
Grupo de Investigación en Salud Pública, Universidad Pontificia Bolivariana, Medellín, Colombia.
Facultad Nacional de Salud Pública, Universidad de Antioquia, Medellín, Colombia.
Front Public Health. 2020 Feb 7;8:16. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2020.00016. eCollection 2020.
People living in long-term care facilities (LTCF) are at high risk to develop active tuberculosis primarily as a result of reactivation of a latent TB infection, or endemic transmission between residents. Current national guidelines in Canada are to use a posterior-anterior and lateral chest X-ray to screen for TB for those over 65 years old, upon admission to a LTCF. To assess the available evidence for cost benefits of universal chest X-ray screening for new LTCF residents. We conducted a search for all articles published until September 2018, in PubMed and WorlCat databases, in English, using a combination of key words: chest X-ray, chest radiography or CXR, long-term care, elderly, screening, and tuberculosis. We also reviewed publicly available guidelines for screening new residents to LTCF from across Canada. We report on a qualitative synthesis of the evidence in the documents retrieved. The final review yielded four cost-effectiveness studies (2 of 4 conducted in countries with low incidence), one systematic review, one recommendation/editorial, and one cohort study. We found that in a tuberculosis low-incidence country the CXR cost per identified case was $672,298 CAD. Enacting a more targeted screening program, perhaps one that tests only those who previously had TB, or other high-risk medical conditions may enhance the cost-effectiveness. We suggest reviewing the screening policy for active TB in people entering LTCF, which is based on a CXR. The results indicate that a targeted search for active TB in people with symptoms or other high-risk medical conditions may be more cost-effective.
居住在长期护理机构(LTCF)的人群主要由于潜伏性结核感染的重新激活或居民之间的地方性传播,而面临发生活动性结核病的高风险。加拿大目前的国家指南是,对于65岁以上入住LTCF的人员,采用后前位和侧位胸部X光片进行结核病筛查。为了评估对新入住LTCF的居民进行普遍胸部X光筛查的成本效益的现有证据。我们在PubMed和WorldCat数据库中搜索了截至2018年9月发表的所有英文文章,使用了关键词组合:胸部X光、胸部放射摄影或CXR、长期护理、老年人、筛查和结核病。我们还查阅了加拿大各地关于筛查新入住LTCF居民的公开指南。我们报告了对检索到的文献中的证据进行的定性综合分析。最终审查产生了四项成本效益研究(其中两项在发病率较低的国家进行)、一项系统评价、一项推荐/社论和一项队列研究。我们发现,在结核病低发病率国家,每确诊一例病例的CXR成本为672,298加元。制定一个更有针对性的筛查计划,也许只对那些以前患过结核病或有其他高风险医疗状况的人进行检测,可能会提高成本效益。我们建议审查基于CXR的入住LTCF人员活动性结核病筛查政策。结果表明,对有症状或其他高风险医疗状况的人群进行针对性的活动性结核病筛查可能更具成本效益。