Steinbrück K, Wiehmann J C
Sportklinik Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt.
Z Orthop Ihre Grenzgeb. 1988 May-Jun;126(3):289-95. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1040205.
Purely clinical examination of the knee joint can, at best, only be regarded as a "screening procedure". Diagnosis with the aid of apparatus (sonography, arthrography, CT, NMR) produces better results. However, arthroscopy performed by an experienced examiner confirms the diagnosis in cases of suspected meniscus injury or isolated lesions of the cruciate ligaments and leads to early and therefore optimal therapy. In a retrospective study 300 arthroscopies performed in 1985 were selected and evaluated. In 1986/87, a further 300 patients were clinically examined prospectively, according to the same criteria, and findings were compared with the arthroscopy performed the following day. Clinically, in 287 patients with multiple diagnoses, internal meniscus lesions were diagnosed in 162 cases (54%), external meniscus lesions in 38 (13%), chondropathia patellae in 54 (18%), and old ruptures of the cruciate ligaments in 46 (15%). In 13 patients no diagnosis could be established. Arthroscopically, pathology of the internal meniscus was found in 98 (33%) of the 300 patients, of the external meniscus in 40 (13%), cartilage damage in 103 (34%), old cruciate ligament ruptures in 51 (17%), and recent anterior cruciate ligament ruptures in 156 (52%); in 40 cases findings were normal. At 78%, the highest positive predictive value (proportion of tentative clinical diagnoses confirmed by arthroscopy) was found in cases of old ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament, followed by external meniscus lesions (61%) and internal meniscus lesions (55%); i.e., only 55 out of 100 clinically suspected internal meniscus lesions are diagnosed by arthroscopy.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
对膝关节进行单纯的临床检查,充其量只能被视为一种“筛查程序”。借助仪器(超声、关节造影、CT、核磁共振)进行诊断能取得更好的结果。然而,由经验丰富的检查者进行的关节镜检查,对于疑似半月板损伤或交叉韧带孤立性损伤的病例,能够确诊并带来早期且因此是最佳的治疗。在一项回顾性研究中,选取并评估了1985年进行的300例关节镜检查。1986/87年,又根据相同标准对另外300例患者进行了前瞻性临床检查,并将检查结果与次日进行的关节镜检查结果进行比较。临床上,在287例有多种诊断结果的患者中,诊断出内侧半月板损伤162例(54%),外侧半月板损伤38例(13%),髌骨软骨病54例(18%),陈旧性交叉韧带断裂46例(15%)。13例患者无法确诊。关节镜检查发现,300例患者中内侧半月板病变98例(33%),外侧半月板病变40例(13%),软骨损伤103例(34%),陈旧性交叉韧带断裂51例(17%),近期前交叉韧带断裂156例(52%);40例检查结果正常。在前交叉韧带陈旧性断裂病例中,阳性预测值(关节镜检查证实的初步临床诊断比例)最高,为78%,其次是外侧半月板损伤(61%)和内侧半月板损伤(55%);也就是说,100例临床上疑似内侧半月板损伤的病例中,只有55例通过关节镜检查确诊。(摘要截取自250字)