Zhang Y Q, Li H, Wu H H, Zong X N
Department of Growth and Development, Capital Institute of Pediatrics, Beijing 100020, China.
Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi. 2020 Mar 2;58(3):206-212. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0578-1310.2020.03.009.
To investigate the timing of permanent tooth emergence and its association with physical growth among children aged 4-7 years in 9 cities of China, and to analyze the trend of permanent teeth development. According to a stratified cluster sampling design, a cross-sectional survey on the timing of permanent tooth emergence children aged 4-7 years was carried out in 9 cities (Beijing, Harbin and Xi'an in northern China; Shanghai, Nanjing and Wuhan in central China; Guangzhou, Fuzhou and Kunming in southern China) from June to October in 2015. A total of 37 973 children (19 035 boys and 18 938 girls) were recruited and were divided into different age groups (4.0-<4.5, 4.5-5.0, 5.0-5.5 and 6.0-<7.0 years of age). The situation of the exfoliation of primary teeth and the eruption of permanent teeth were investigated. Height and weight were measured using the standardized methods. Z-scores of physical growth indicators were calculated using the growth standards for Chinese children in 2009. Probit regression analysis was used to determine the median and percentile age of transition from deciduous to permanent teeth. Chi-square test was used for comparison of categorical data and test was used for comparison of measurement data between boys and girls, urban and suburban as well as among different ages and regions. Meanwhile, the data from the national survey on physical growth and development of children under 7 years of age in 9 cities of China in 1995 were used to analyze the trends of the permanent teeth development. The rate of transition from deciduous to permanent teeth in 37 973 children aged 4-7 years was higher with age, which was 0.6% (42/7 568) in 4.0-<4.5 years of age group, 30.3% (2 295/7 583) in 5.5-<6.0 years of age group, and 74.5% (5 680/7 627) in 6.0-<7.0 years of age group. The rates of transition from deciduous to permanent teeth in boys were all lower than those of girls except for children aged 4.0-<4.5 years (all 0.01). The rate of transition from deciduous to permanent teeth in urban children was higher than that in suburban children for older than 5.5-6.0 years of age group in boys and older than 4.5-5.0 years of age group in girls, which was 74.2% (1 427/1 924) in urban boys aged 6.0-<7.0 years and 69.2% (1 305/1 885) in suburban boys aged 6.0-<7.0 years (χ(2)=11.446, 0.01). The age of transition from deciduous to permanent teeth was 6.00 (95: 5.98-6.01) years and the range of the 3-97 percentile was 4.88-7.11 years of age. The median permanent tooth emergence age of girls was lower than that of boys (5.94 6.06 years) and the median age of urban children was lower than that of suburban children (5.94 6.05 years). The median permanent tooth emergence age of southern Chinese children (6.05 years) was higher than that of northern (5.97 years) and central Chinese children (5.97 years). The weight for age Z-scores (WAZ), height for age Z-scores (HAZ) and body mass index for age Z-scores (BMIZ) of children with transition from deciduous to permanent teeth (0.35±1.17, 0.32±1.00, 0.23±1.16) were significantly higher than those of children without transition from deciduous to permanent teeth (0.03±1.13, 0.03±1.02, 0.04±1.13, 20.81,21.67,12.09, all 0.05). In comparison with the data in 1995, data in 2015 showed that the rate of transition from deciduous to permanent teeth was higher, for example, the rate of urban boys aged 6.0-<7.0 years group was 63.8% (1 146/1 796) in 1995, and increased to 74.2% (1 427/1 924) in 2015 (χ(2)=46.748, 0.01). The median permanent tooth emergence age decreased by 0.24 years in 2015 as compared with that in 1995. The development of permanent teeth is earlier in girls than in boys, earlier in urban children than in suburban children and slightly delay in southern children than in central and northern Chinese children. In addition, the development of permanent teeth, which is related to the physical growth, slightly accelerate in China during the past 20 years.
为调查中国9个城市4-7岁儿童恒牙萌出时间及其与身体生长的关系,并分析恒牙发育趋势。按照分层整群抽样设计,于2015年6月至10月对9个城市(中国北方的北京、哈尔滨和西安;中国中部的上海、南京和武汉;中国南方的广州、福州和昆明)4-7岁儿童恒牙萌出时间进行横断面调查。共招募37973名儿童(19035名男孩和18938名女孩),并分为不同年龄组(4.0-<4.5、4.5-5.0、5.0-5.5和6.0-<7.0岁)。调查乳牙脱落和恒牙萌出情况。采用标准化方法测量身高和体重。根据2009年中国儿童生长标准计算身体生长指标的Z评分。采用概率回归分析确定乳牙向恒牙转变的中位年龄和百分位数年龄。采用卡方检验比较分类数据,采用t检验比较男孩和女孩、城市和郊区以及不同年龄和地区之间的计量数据。同时,利用1995年中国9个城市7岁以下儿童身体生长发育全国调查的数据,分析恒牙发育趋势。37973名4-7岁儿童乳牙向恒牙转变的发生率随年龄增加,4.0-<4.5岁年龄组为0.6%(42/7568),5.5-<6.0岁年龄组为30.3%(2295/7583),6.0-<7.0岁年龄组为74.5%(5680/7627)。除4.0-<4.5岁儿童外,男孩乳牙向恒牙转变的发生率均低于女孩(均P<0.01)。对于男孩,5.5-6.0岁以上年龄组城市儿童乳牙向恒牙转变的发生率高于郊区儿童,对于女孩,4.5-5.0岁以上年龄组城市儿童乳牙向恒牙转变的发生率高于郊区儿童,6.0-<7.0岁城市男孩为74.2%(1427/1924),6.0-<7.0岁郊区男孩为69.2%(1305/1885)(χ²=11.446,P<0.01)。乳牙向恒牙转变的年龄为6.00(95%CI:5.98-6.01)岁,3-97百分位数范围为4.88-7.11岁。女孩恒牙萌出的中位年龄低于男孩(5.94对6.06岁),城市儿童的中位年龄低于郊区儿童(5.94对6.05岁)。中国南方儿童恒牙萌出的中位年龄(6.05岁)高于北方(5.97岁)和中部地区儿童(5.97岁)。乳牙向恒牙转变儿童的年龄别体重Z评分(WAZ)、年龄别身高Z评分(HAZ)和年龄别体重指数Z评分(BMIZ)(0.35±1.17、0.32±1.00、0.23±1.16)显著高于未发生乳牙向恒牙转变的儿童(0.03±1.13、0.03±1.02、0.04±1.13,t=20.81、21.67、12.09,均P<0.05)。与1995年数据相比,2015年数据显示乳牙向恒牙转变的发生率更高,例如,1995年6.0-<7.0岁城市男孩组的发生率为63.8%(1146/1796),2015年增至74.2%(1427/1924)(χ²=46.748,P<0.01)。与1995年相比,2015年恒牙萌出的中位年龄下降了0.24岁。恒牙发育女孩早于男孩,城市儿童早于郊区儿童,中国南方儿童略晚于中部和北方儿童。此外,与身体生长相关的恒牙发育在过去20年中在中国略有加速。