Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
J Arthroplasty. 2020 Aug;35(8):2188-2194. doi: 10.1016/j.arth.2020.02.012. Epub 2020 Feb 13.
Unconstrained tripolar articulations have been theorized to increase hip stability. The purpose of this study is to report the performance of tripolar articulations in revision THA and identify factors associated with success and failure.
Between 1994 and 2016, 67 revision THAs were performed with an unconstrained tripolar articulation. Mean follow-up was 5.4 years. Patient charts were retrospectively reviewed emphasizing factors associated with risk of instability. There were 21 patients with neither a history of instability (HI) nor abductor insufficiency (AI), 20 patients with HI alone, 13 with AI alone, and 13 had both HI and AI.
Twelve THAs sustained at least one postrevision dislocation at an average of 2.1 years. One bipolar dissociation occurred early (1.2 y). Nine hips had a re-revision to address these complications. Survival free from dislocation at 2, 5, and 10 years was 88%, 85%, and 74%, respectively. Survival free from re-revision at 2, 5, and 10 years was 91%, 84%, and 65%, respectively. Patients with combined AI and HI had the worst survivorship free from dislocation at 2, 5, and 10 years (77%, 68%, and 55%), respectively. In contrast, patients with neither HI nor AI experienced zero dislocations. There were no failures associated with bearing wear.
Off-the-shelf tripolar articulations were associated with reasonable survival at midterm follow-up. In patients with both AI and HI, the risks and benefits of alternative options such as dual mobility or constrained liners should be explored as the risk of dislocation at 10 years approached 50%.
无约束的三极关节被认为可以增加髋关节稳定性。本研究旨在报告三极关节在翻修 THA 中的应用效果,并确定与成功和失败相关的因素。
1994 年至 2016 年间,67 例翻修 THA 采用无约束三极关节,平均随访 5.4 年。回顾性分析患者病历,重点关注与不稳定风险相关的因素。其中 21 例患者既无不稳定(HI)病史,也无外展肌功能不全(AI),20 例仅 HI,13 例 AI 单独存在,13 例同时存在 HI 和 AI。
12 例 THA 在平均 2.1 年后至少发生 1 次翻修后脱位。1 例双极分离发生在早期(1.2 年)。9 髋需再次翻修以解决这些并发症。2、5、10 年无脱位生存率分别为 88%、85%和 74%。2、5、10 年无再翻修生存率分别为 91%、84%和 65%。同时存在 AI 和 HI 的患者 2、5、10 年无脱位生存率最差(77%、68%和 55%)。相反,既无 HI 也无 AI 的患者未发生脱位。无与轴承磨损相关的失败。
市售三极关节在中期随访中具有较好的生存率。对于同时存在 AI 和 HI 的患者,应探讨双动或约束衬垫等替代方案的风险和获益,因为 10 年时的脱位风险接近 50%。