McManus Chris
Research Department of Clinical, Educational and Health Psychology, University College London, London, UK.
Brain Neurosci Adv. 2019 May 6;3:2398212818820513. doi: 10.1177/2398212818820513. eCollection 2019 Jan-Dec.
Although most people are right-handed and have language in their left cerebral hemisphere, why that is so, and in particular why about ten per cent of people are left-handed, is far from clear. Multiple theories have been proposed, often with little in the way of empirical support, and sometimes indeed with strong evidence against them, and yet despite that have become modern urban myths, probably due to the symbolic power of right and left. One thinks in particular of ideas of being right-brained or left-brained, of suggestions that left-handedness is due to perinatal brain damage, of claims that left-handers die seven years earlier than right-handers, and of the unfalsifiable ramifications of the byzantine Geschwind-Behan-Galaburda theory. This article looks back over the past fifty years of research on brain asymmetries, exploring the different themes and approaches, sometimes in relation to the author's own work. Taking all of the work together it is probable that cerebral asymmetries are under genetic control, probably with multiple genetic loci, only a few of which are now beginning to be found thanks to very large databases that are becoming available. Other progress is also seen in proper meta-analyses, the use of fMRI for studying multiple functional lateralisations in large number of individuals, fetal ultra-sound for assessing handedness before birth, and fascinating studies of lateralisation in an ever widening range of animal species. With luck the next fifty years will make more progress and show fewer false directions than had much of the work in the previous fifty years.
虽然大多数人习惯用右手,且语言功能位于左脑半球,但为何如此,尤其是为何约10%的人习惯用左手,却远未明确。人们提出了多种理论,很多时候这些理论几乎没有实证支持,有时甚至有强有力的证据反驳它们,但尽管如此,它们还是成了现代都市传说,这可能是因为左右的象征意义。人们尤其会想到右脑或左脑的概念、认为左撇子是由于围产期脑损伤的观点、声称左撇子比右撇子早死七年的说法,以及拜占庭式的盖什温 - 贝汉 - 加拉布尔达理论那些无法证伪的分支。本文回顾了过去五十年来关于大脑不对称性的研究,探讨了不同的主题和方法,有时还涉及作者自己的工作。综合所有这些研究来看,大脑不对称性很可能受基因控制,可能涉及多个基因位点,由于可用的大型数据库,现在才开始发现其中少数几个基因位点。在恰当的荟萃分析、使用功能磁共振成像研究大量个体的多种功能偏侧化、利用胎儿超声评估出生前的用手习惯以及对越来越多动物物种的偏侧化进行引人入胜的研究等方面也取得了其他进展。幸运的话,未来五十年将比过去五十年的许多研究取得更多进展,出现的错误方向也更少。