El-Gammal Tarek Abdalla, Ali Amr El-Sayed, Kotb Mohamed Mostafa, Saleh Waleed Riad, El-Gammal Yousif Tarek
From the Hand and Reconstructive Microsurgery Unit.
Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, Faculty of Medicine, Assiut University, Assiut, Egypt.
Ann Plast Surg. 2020 May;84(5):565-569. doi: 10.1097/SAP.0000000000002288.
The long-term results of soft tissue rebalancing procedures of the shoulder in obstetric brachial plexus palsy have been scarcely reported. The effect of this procedure on the evolution of secondary bone changes has been a subject of controversy.
Twenty-six children are included in this study. All initially had postganglionic C5-6 or C5-7 (Narakas types I and II) obstetric brachial plexus palsy, which spontaneously recovered. Children included are those who had persistent external rotation weakness with or without internal rotation contracture, nondysplastic glenohumeral joint, and functioning teres major. All had anterior shoulder release and teres major to infraspinatus transfer to correct internal rotation deformity and/or increase active shoulder external rotation. Patients were 18 males and 8 females. The right upper limb was affected in 16 patients, and the left in 10. Surgery was performed at an average age of 3.01 years (range, 1-10 years). Follow-up averaged 8.2 years (range, 5-16 years). Eight cases (30%) were followed up for 10 years or greater. Age at final follow-up averaged 10.5 years (range, 6-17.8 years).
The results showed to be significant: 67 degrees (63%), 71.3 degrees (412%), and -32 degrees (-35%), respectively. There was no single recurrence of internal rotation deformity. Global Mallet score averaged 20 ± 2.7. Global abduction and external rotation averaged 3.5 ± 0.8 and 4 ± 0.3, respectively. Shoulder abduction range included an average of 45 degrees glenohumeral and 65 degrees scapulothoracic motion. Postoperative internal rotation in adduction was limited to 55.96 ± 25.65 degrees and was significantly lower that the preoperative value. Radiological measurements showed no significant differences between the operated and normal sides.
We conclude that the long-term results after soft tissue rebalancing, combined with open reduction when required, demonstrated significant improvement of abduction and external rotation and significant loss of internal rotation. The difference in glenoid version and humeral head subluxation continued to be insignificant compared with the normal side.
关于产科臂丛神经麻痹肩部软组织平衡手术的长期结果鲜有报道。该手术对继发性骨骼变化演变的影响一直存在争议。
本研究纳入了26名儿童。所有患儿最初均患有节后C5 - 6或C5 - 7(Narakas I型和II型)产科臂丛神经麻痹,且均自发恢复。纳入的儿童为存在持续性外旋无力伴或不伴内旋挛缩、非发育不良性盂肱关节以及功能正常的大圆肌的患儿。所有患儿均接受了前路肩部松解术以及大圆肌转位至冈下肌手术,以纠正内旋畸形和/或增加肩部主动外旋。患者中男性18例,女性8例。16例患者右侧上肢受累,10例左侧上肢受累。手术平均年龄为3.01岁(范围1 - 10岁)。平均随访8.2年(范围5 - 16年)。8例(30%)随访时间达10年或更长。末次随访时平均年龄为10.5岁(范围6 - 17.8岁)。
结果显示具有显著性:分别为67度(63%)、71.3度(412%)和 - 32度( - 35%)。内旋畸形无复发。Mallet总体评分平均为20 ± 2.7。总体外展和外旋平均分别为3.5 ± 0.8和4 ± 0.3。肩部外展范围平均包括盂肱关节活动45度和肩胛胸壁活动65度。内收位术后内旋受限至55.96 ± 25.65度,显著低于术前值。影像学测量显示手术侧与正常侧之间无显著差异。
我们得出结论,软组织平衡手术后的长期结果,结合必要时的切开复位,显示外展和外旋有显著改善,内旋有显著丧失。与正常侧相比,关节盂形态和肱骨头半脱位的差异仍然不显著。