Gabrick Kyle, Smetona John, Iyengar Rajiv, Dinis Jacob, Chouiari Fouad, Peck Connor J, Persing John, Alperovich Michael
Section of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Department of Surgery, Yale University School of Medicine.
Frank H. Netter School of Medicine, North Haven, CT.
J Craniofac Surg. 2020 Jun;31(4):e388-e391. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000006356.
Orbital floor fractures are common injuries treated by multiple surgical subspecialties. Controversy exists regarding the operative indications. This study sought to correlate radiographic characteristics of orbital floor fractures with validated patient reported outcome measures following non-operative management.
Patients who underwent non-operative management of an orbital floor fracture at Yale New Haven Hospital from 2013 to 2018 were queried retrospectively. Patients with GCS < 15 and/or distracting facial soft tissue or bony injuries were excluded from analysis. CT images, demographic information, and FACE-Q patient reported outcomes (Satisfaction with Eyes, Psychological Function, Social Function, and Appearance Related Psychosocial Distress) were reviewed. Statistical analysis was performed with SPSS with statistical significance set at P < .05.
Eighteen patients were included in the study. The mean time between injury and completion of the survey was 3.6 years. Fifty-six percent of patients had a right-sided fracture. The mean fracture area was 73.6 mm (Range:15-172 mm), and 913 mm (Range: 0-3106) was the mean volume displaced into the maxillary sinus. The unaffected inferior rectus muscle shape (height/width) was 0.5 (Range: 0.2-0.98) compared to 0.8 (Range 0.4-1.6) for the affected inferior rectus. After controlling for the time interval between survey and injury, gender, income, and education, rounding of the inferior rectus muscle was a significant predictor of appearance related psychosocial distress (P = 0.006). Inferior rectus rounding was stratified into "severe" (75%) and "moderate" (25%) categories. Severe rounding was associated with a larger orbital floor fracture area (110 versus 64 mm; P = 0.074), volume displaced into the maxillary sinus (1,716 versus 610 mm; P = 0.024), and worse appearance-related psychosocial distress (70 versus 25; P = 0.013). Sixty-one percent of patients followed up in clinic with a mean duration of 194 days.
Prior studies have correlated presenting radiographic findings to follow-up clinical findings. However, this study is the first to assess long-term outcomes using validated patient-reported questionnaires. Inferior rectus muscle belly rounding significantly correlated with appearance related psychosocial distress. This radiographic finding may be valuable to consider in orbital floor fracture management.
眶底骨折是常见损伤,由多个外科亚专业进行治疗。关于手术指征存在争议。本研究旨在将眶底骨折的影像学特征与非手术治疗后经过验证的患者报告结局指标相关联。
对2013年至2018年在耶鲁纽黑文医院接受眶底骨折非手术治疗的患者进行回顾性查询。格拉斯哥昏迷评分(GCS)<15分和/或伴有面部软组织或骨组织牵张性损伤的患者被排除在分析之外。对CT图像、人口统计学信息以及患者报告的FACE-Q结局(对眼睛的满意度、心理功能、社会功能以及外貌相关心理社会困扰)进行了评估。使用SPSS进行统计分析,设定统计学显著性为P<0.05。
18例患者纳入研究。受伤至完成调查的平均时间为3.6年。56%的患者为右侧骨折。平均骨折面积为73.6平方毫米(范围:15 - 172平方毫米),平均有913立方毫米(范围:0 - 3106立方毫米)的组织移位至上颌窦。未受影响的下直肌形状(高度/宽度)为0.5(范围:0.2 - 0.98),而受影响的下直肌为0.8(范围:0.4 - 1.6)。在控制了调查与受伤之间的时间间隔、性别、收入和教育程度后,下直肌圆钝是外貌相关心理社会困扰的显著预测因素(P = 0.006)。下直肌圆钝分为“严重”(75%)和“中度”(25%)两类。严重圆钝与更大的眶底骨折面积(110平方毫米对64平方毫米;P = 0.074)、移位至上颌窦的体积(1716立方毫米对610立方毫米;P = 0.024)以及更差的外貌相关心理社会困扰(70对25;P = 0.013)相关。61%的患者在门诊进行了随访,平均随访时长为194天。
既往研究已将初始影像学表现与随访临床结果相关联。然而,本研究是首次使用经过验证的患者报告问卷评估长期结局。下直肌肌腹圆钝与外貌相关心理社会困扰显著相关。这一影像学发现可能在眶底骨折治疗中具有重要参考价值。