Kendell R E
University Department of Psychiatry, Royal Edinburgh Hospital, Scotland.
Schizophr Bull. 1988;14(4):663-7. doi: 10.1093/schbul/14.4.663.
Recent followup studies establish that schizophrenia, however defined, is a disease of very variable outcome. Many patients recover completely and improvements can occur after many years. This is difficult to reconcile with the concept of slowly progressive brain disease, and it seems increasingly likely that the neuropathology observed in chronic schizophrenia largely precedes the onset of symptoms. The adverse effect of a hostile or overprotective emotional environment on the prognosis of schizophrenia, and recently reported differences in family environments between industrial and Third World countries, may account for the relatively good outcome of schizophrenia in the latter. Despite its many imperfections, the concept of schizophrenia is unlikely to be abandoned until we have radical new insights into the etiology of the "functional psychoses."
近期的随访研究证实,无论如何定义,精神分裂症都是一种预后差异很大的疾病。许多患者能完全康复,且多年后仍可能有所改善。这很难与缓慢进展性脑病的概念相协调,而且越来越有可能的是,在慢性精神分裂症中观察到的神经病理学变化在很大程度上先于症状的出现。充满敌意或过度保护的情感环境对精神分裂症预后的不利影响,以及最近报道的工业化国家和第三世界国家家庭环境的差异,可能解释了后者中精神分裂症相对较好的预后。尽管存在诸多缺陷,但在我们对“功能性精神病”的病因有全新的深刻见解之前,精神分裂症的概念不太可能被摒弃。